3 ms·
> as soon as I begin broadcasting, I'm not just living my life any more, I'm affecting yours, too Do you have a wifi router? If so, you are already broadcastin
by pdonis 11y ago
> as soon as I begin broadcasting, I'm not just living my life any more, I'm affecting yours, too
Do you have a wifi router? If so, you are already broadcasting. Have your neighbors complained that they can't use their wifi because of your broadcasting?
The huge missing piece in this whole discussion, to me, is: how much of a problem actually exists? How many people actually have problems using wifi because someone else is violating the FCC rules? My sense is that the number is very small.
> Pre-emptive regulation of the sort the FCC engages in is annoying
I think it's much worse than annoying. Perhaps you don't do any hacking on any device that has a wifi radio; if so, it might only be annoying to you. But if even a small number of people who want to innovate (and won't be doing anything that would break the rules anyway) are prevented from doing so because of pre-emptive regulation, that is a big price to pay. Particularly if, as I suggested above, the magnitude of the actual problem is small.
> what other mechanism is proposed to prevent spectrum abuse?
The article suggests two: social norms, and aggressive enforcement against actual offenders--as in the Marriott case.
- anigbrowl 11y agoMy neighbors haven't complained because I'm not doing anything particularly radical with my router. But if I started swamping their signals I imagine they would be annoyed about it. I thought this context was obvious in my post above. The article suggests two: social norms, and aggressive enforcement against actual offenders--as in the Marriott case. And people who disagree with our perspective thought the Marriott case was a big government shakedown. I am disinclined to rely on social norms, given that there are often substantial economic rewards for flouting them.
- pdonis 11y ago> My neighbors haven't complained because I'm not doing anything particularly radical with my router. But if I started swamping their signals I imagine they would be annoyed about it. But you're not swamping their signals. Neither are the vast majority of people who have routers. So the vast majority of people are not hindering each other by broadcasting. That includes many people (like me) who have routers with third party open source firmware on them (I run OpenWRT). Just saying "well, someone could swamp others' signals" isn't enough to justify pre-emptive regulation; that should require showing that enough people are swamping others' signals to make ordinary enforcement insufficient. > people who disagree with our perspective thought the Marriott case was a big government shakedown How do you think those people would view pre-emptive regulation by the government? > I am disinclined to rely on social norms, given that there are often substantial economic rewards for flouting them. I see the economic incentive in the case of a large corporation like Marriott (and that's why I mentioned them in connection with enforcement, not social norms). But for ordinary users who just want to run routers in their homes? Social norms seems like a reasonable way to regulate in that case.