4 ms·
As unbiased as I can put it: - Dustin Curtis, a freelance (?) designer, posted a spec redesign of the American Airlines main page, along with a scathing blog p
by potatolicious 17y ago
As unbiased as I can put it:
- Dustin Curtis, a freelance (?) designer, posted a spec redesign of the American Airlines main page, along with a scathing blog post about how bad the existing site is, accusing AA's online team of gross incompetence, and calling for their mass firing. HN reacts overall negatively to what is perceived as a presumptuous attitude, along with several potentially major shortcomings in his own redesign.
- A member of AA's online team contacted Dustin directly to defend himself and his team - and offer insight as to why things are the way they are. This individual permitted Dustin to post his response, which he did. This resulted in the individual's firing from AA.
- A few equally scathing blog posts were written about Mr. Curtis' professionalism in this matter - IIRC mostly concentrating on the combative, aggressive tone of the original post, the lack of understanding of enterprise-level web design, and his cavalier attitude when it came to the responses to his original post. These, in turn, generate more controversy.
- Mz 17y agoStuff like that has a tendency to become a persistent fly in the ointment of a forum. Attacks and criticisms beget more attacks and criticisms. Often, later attacks are done with some intention of stopping the cycle. But fighting against the fighting is still fighting. Thanks for the run down.