4 ms·
This was 40+ years ago. If such things were actually possible, with the advance of information technology we should see more, not less, of these accomplishments
by sandworm101 11y ago
This was 40+ years ago. If such things were actually possible, with the advance of information technology we should see more, not less, of these accomplishments recorded. We should see cellphone footage from every angle of yogis who can fly. We should have ground-penetrating radar and webcam thermal imaging of those burying themselves.
There is a line in the movie Close Encounters about how car accidents are real but had never been filmed (the point being that a lack of footage does not mean UFOs are not real). That was 1977. We now have millions more cameras and plenty of recorded car accidents because car accidents are in fact real. Conversely, bigfoot and UFO footage has all but disappeared with the increased numbers of cameras. Bigfoot is not real. Neither are these superhuman yogis. No doubt they can survive longer in harsh environments than the average person, but they cannot violate the laws of physics. If they could, we would rewrite those laws and hand them noble prizes for their work.
- chm 11y agoWe can push this further and expect your "reality test" to become practically useless some time in the next 50 years. That is, when no matter how well you analyze a video/picture, you can not tell if it is CG or not. What happens when, in the next 150 years say, one cannot identify with appreciable probability [1] whether someone is human or not? [1]: À la Turing test, but with a humanoid robot.
- sandworm101 11y agoSomething standing in front of me that cannot be scientifically proven not to be human, would be a human. A robot that accurate down to the microscopic may be a synthetically-grown human but nevertheless still a human being. CGI will always be behind the curve. Science requires repeatability by independent researchers. A CGI hoax cannot survive independent footage of the event. So CGI cannot survive scientific scrutiny. It can certainly survive fake scrutiny (see viral vids) but not real investigation by people looking for the hoax.
- EGreg 11y agoI think all our current systems (democracy, laws, courts, basic trust) rely on human level attackers who can't adapt quickly enough to beat the system every time. But I think that in the future many of these assumptions will be overturned and our systems will literally be fooled by AI. Your expectations of what AI will not be able to produce via "hacking" our systems and expectations will be far surpassed. And then what do we do? Simple short term example: how do our current political systems prevent the proliferation of rogue drones programmed by completely anonymous individuals to wreak havoc? Or computer viruses? We are just relying on the absence of a capable adversary, same as with security by obscurity.
- chm 11y agoConsider this scenario: You're walking down the street and a small woman walks past you and stumbles. You help her up and she says thanks, then gets back on her way. How can you "scientifically" prove whether she was a human or not? Of course you could put her on an operating table and cut her open... but she moves and breathes and feels everything as a human. How could you force that treatment upon her? And then you'd have to do it for everybody else. How do you know the surgeon isn't a humanoid robot? How do you know you're not a robot yourself?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dalke 11y agoConsider than in 150 years there may be several hundred videos of something happening, from a variety of angles, where the devices are controlled by multiple, independent agents. While one stream can be faked, it would require large-scale collusion or subversion to fake the large majority of videos.
- tunesmith 11y agoI know little, but I thought I had read that yogic "flying" is just a misnomer - they're in the lotus position and kind of hop around on their knees (I've seen footage of that), but the word for it kind of roughly translates to flying. I haven't heard/seen claims of literal flying though.
- dalke 11y agohttp://www.amazingabilities.com/amaze9a.html http://www.amazingabilities.com/amaze9a.html > There are various stages of Yogic Flying. The initial stage is "hopping." The second stage is "floating," and the final stage is "flying." So far, no one practicing the Yogic Flying TM-Sidhi has been observed achieving a stage beyond hopping. Achieving the floating and flying stages is dependent upon the extent to which the practitioner is able to sustain his awareness at the level of the unified field, the level of transcendental consciousness. It is by maintaining one's awareness at this very fine level that one is able to influence the laws of nature to gain support of those laws whereby anything is possible. That is why the unified field is called the field of all possibilities; from that most fundamental and powerful level anything is possible. The author believes that eventually the final stage of levitation (flying) will be a common phenomenon. This sort of flying comes out of Transcendental Mediation from the 1970s. You are right that this kind of hop is labeled "flying", even though it isn't flying. However, I think sandworm101's comment of "yogis who can fly" should be read more generally to include levitation. For example, quoting from "Autobiography of a Yogi" at http://www.crystalclarity.com/yogananda/chap7.php http://www.crystalclarity.com/yogananda/chap7.php (and also mentioned in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saints_and_levitation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saints_and_levitation ): > "I saw a yogi remain in the air, several feet above the ground, last night at a group meeting." My friend, Upendra Mohun Chowdhury, spoke impressively. > ... "How does he remain in the air, defying the law of gravitation?" > "A yogi's body loses its grossness after use of certain pranayamas. Then it will levitate or hop about like a leaping frog. Even saints who do not practice a formal yoga[4] have been known to levitate during a state of intense devotion to God." The footnote 4 mentions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teresa_of_%C3%81vila https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teresa_of_%C3%81vila , who was "said to have been observed levitating during Mass on more than one occasion". Then there's https://books.google.com/books?id=mSpQAQAAQBAJ&pg=PT26&dq=yogi+levitate&hl=en&sa=X&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=yogi%20levitate&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=mSpQAQAAQBAJ&pg=PT26&dq=yo... ("The Autobiography of the Maha Yogi") > ... It is the law the governs the life of a yogi, (an equivalent to the Arian law of the Buddhits that governs the conducts of the Bodhisattvas) that forbid he yogi to demonstrate his paranormal and supernatural powers in the presence of savages and barbarians, before the public or in front of television cameras. Yet, I am the only living contemporary who ever levitated four feet off the ground in front of a camera. I shall, of course, refrain from ever levitating in public, as a matter of fundamental principle for that would be a sacrilege. Furthermore, like several of my Siddhies, levitation in [sic] an Involuntary occurrence that happens in rare moments of religious ecstasy, perhaps as few as one or two times per year. There was no known yogi in history who has been able to levitate at will and on demand. That's two yogis who claim something that sounds more than kind of hopping. After all, hopping can be done at will and on demand.
- tpeo 11y ago>with the advance of information technology we should see more, not less, of these accomplishments recorded This is an over sophisticated way to say "no evidence, no thing". I don't intend to defend the existence of big foot (which I think is a silly comparison), but if asked about it I'd rather make no claims about it. The answer to whether it happened or not is moo.
- sandworm101 11y agoIt's not that simple. I'm talking about phenomena for which we have lots of evidence. There is lots of evidence for Bigfoot and UFOs, but amount does not equate to quality or proof. My point is that with the increased number and quality of cameras and lower burden of creating footage we should see exponentially more footage over time rather than less. The recording of real phenomena should be directly related to the number and quality of cameras or other recording devices (see rogue waves, shark attacks). Phenomena that seem inversely related or at least disconnected from the spread of cameras (Bigfoot, UFOs etc) become less likely to be real over time. We still get occasional new footage or other evidence, but it doesn't fit the curve followed by known real phenomena.
- dalke 11y agoThe relevant xkcd is https://xkcd.com/1235/ https://xkcd.com/1235/ . The commentary here now reflects the comments in the thread at http://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/1235 http://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/1235 .
- khed 11y agoI would be curious to know if you can actually state nonstrawmen arguments in support of UFO's. What is the strongest case that can be made for UFO's? Do you know what it is? If you do, can you reasonably refute it?
- aidenn0 11y agoThe absence of evidence is evidence of absence in the case where you would expect there to be evidence. The fact that we don't have video footage of Egyptian Pharos is in no way evidence for them not existing, since they are purported to have existed prior to the invention of the video camera. Things that are purported to happen today should have good quality recordings of them if they are at all common.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- khed 11y agoThe general point you make is reasonable but it doesn't really apply to this specific situation. How often are people looking for behaviors like this? There are many occasions where we don't see things because we don't look for them. Your point probably works for bigfoot, but it isn't applicable to whether some obscure meditation practice can stop the heart.