3 ms·
As I said the last time this story got discussed on HN: just because it's publishable, doesn't mean it's publishable in a physics journal. The method they're u
by SilasX 11y ago
As I said the last time this story got discussed on HN: just because it's publishable, doesn't mean it's publishable in a physics journal. The method they're using would provide a nice, orthogonal, independent piece of evidence on the topic of time travel.
However, it doesn't fall into a physicist's area of expertise (sorry, "wheelhouse" is the hip term now). Their method depends heavily on related hypotheses about when people would post about things, and thus relies more on the expertise of sociologists and journalists.
So they were right to reject it from physics journals, although they probably should have said, "hey, this would be of greater interest to the guys in this other kind of journal ..."