3 ms·
I kinda feel like you're getting too bogged down in the detail here. I don't think anybody would agree that Thiel is literally 100% correct in saying "technolo
by mindcrime 11y ago
I kinda feel like you're getting too bogged down in the detail here. I don't think anybody would agree that Thiel is literally 100% correct in saying "technology stalled in the 1970's, but if look look at the statement as a bit of hyperbole with a kernel of truth to it, he has a point. And whether you agree with him in general, or not, I think his rhetoric serves a valuable role in terms of encouraging people to reach further, and work on big, hard, fundamental problems.
Anyway, I don't see what he said as being a statement like "I, Peter Thiel, could trivially cure cancer" or anything like that.. I see it as a call to arms to people who are working on, say, ad serving networks, to work on curing cancer instead (where "curing cancer" is a variable that could be replace with any "big, hard, fundamental problem").
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>I see it as a call to arms to people who are working on, say, ad serving networks, to work on curing cancer instead (where "curing cancer" is a variable that could be replace with any "big, hard, fundamental problem"). No, a call to arms for working on big, hard, fundamental problems would be to say, "Let's restructure the scientific career path away from a pyramidal labor and triple funding to the NSF and NIH."
- ChuckMcM 11y agoExcept I think Peter misses the point. He's asserts technology is moving "to slowly" or "to inefficiently" and doesn't seem to have any appreciation for the prerequisites for forward motion. And he dismisses out of hand anything people have done while that foundation is being build. As if having them sit idly by would have been a better use of their time? Imagine you're building a castle, and you've got a quarry full of people cutting the stones to build it, and then you chastise the carpenters who are working on decorative woodwork because there is not enough castle yet to work on. Sure, Google has spent a ton of money building an ad network and figuring out how to get people to click on ads. They have also spent a ton of money on building phone OSes, and build tools, and efficient data centers, and self driving cars. Not everyone can work on curing cancer or creating durable political institutions that survive local corruption. So what do they spend their time on? Building tools, or using those tools to build interesting things which feeds back into better tools. I didn't see any appreciation of the foundational work that has to happen in order for progress to be made in that interview.