3 ms·
Yikes! The reeducation camps must continue! I am telling you this not because I want you to feel sorry for me, but because I want you to understand the danger
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
Yikes! The reeducation camps must continue!
I am telling you this not because I want you to feel sorry for me, but because I want you to understand the danger of writing a well reasoned, logical argument. If you aren't willing to insult and cheat, nobody will ever read what you have to say.
Okay, let's not confuse a bunch of topics.
Topic 1: Rants sell -- just take a look at cable news. People like to watch other people get angry. It's easier than having actual feelings yourself, and there's always the angry-mob "hell yeah!" post you can make at the end.
Topic 2: Insults are spicy. I've found when dealing with the HN news crowd over the years to say "bullshit" instead of "crap" and "hell" instead of "heck". As a former marine, I can curse the chrome off a trailer hitch but learned in my 30s to tone down my language. But, base words sell more than safer words. People love to hear me call you an asshole, even if they like you! But if I respect who you are and ask for clarification of your point? Not so amusing. Better to watch fireworks than not.
Topic 3: If I insult you enough, I don't have to listen to your argument. This is where we cross the line from "how to write for the mob" to "how to shut down reasonable debate". The problem here is that you have entertained us so much we are starting to miss valuable content. For examples of this also see cable news, and some talk radio. This is the Ad Hominem, not the insult. The Ad Hominem is when I am using insult as a tool to prevent you from being heard.
Topic 4: Sometimes it's the people you hate the most that have the most to add to a discussion. This is where you really start screwing over the rest of us. You've done a great job of writing a spicy, insult-laden rant. We're all smiling and nodding with vacant stares as we drool over the keyboard awaiting our Pavlovian response queue. Have we learned anything? Hell no! Have we considered any new points of view? Hell no! Have we done much of all except waste our time? Hell no!
Good writers present both sides of the discussion as fairly as they can and then proceed to make a case. They have a thesis and work towards proving it. And guess what? That's not easy to do in a way that people like. It takes thought, a good vocabulary, a perspicacious terseness.
I read your whole article and it sounded to me like this "I can't write very well, I'm not patient enough to build up a following, I'm frustrated at the capricious nature of HN, and I can't help but notice how much people like to read other people writing smack"
Sure! We can all just fling poo.
But count me out on the poo flinging, at least until I join the rest of the primates at the zoo.
- zby 17y agoIn other words ranting is entertaining but it does not move us ahead.
- dbz 17y agoThe article was suggesting ranting was very pleasant to read- and it is very helpful when correct. The point he made about the game review was that he rants, and he is 100% correct. "No better way to get your point across than to say it and call the person a dumb shit at the same time!" (Although you look ridiculous if you are incorrect, +irony of being the dumb shit)
- zby 17y agoThe problem is not that you look ridiculous - but that nobody would notice that you are incorrect. If someone is always 100% correct that this is a moot point - but I don't think this is a reasonable assumption.