3 ms·
RTBF is primarily meant to redact "untrue" information, so, I find your first response to be... somewhat questionable. In many cases, what RTBF is blocking is l
by ocdtrekkie 11y ago
RTBF is primarily meant to redact "untrue" information, so, I find your first response to be... somewhat questionable. In many cases, what RTBF is blocking is libel. I suppose the notion of "information not relevant to the public interest" may fall under the debate, but most of the claims of "censorship!!!!" clearly focus on concerns that are NOT affected by RTBF laws.
Google's search algorithm has no right to free speech, actually, unless we'd like to define it as an artificial person and grant it Constitutional rights too.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Google's search algorithm has no right to free speech Google's search algorithm is a tool which the people for whom "Google" is simply a legal construct used as a vehicle use in the course of exercising their right to free speech. Restricting the information that can be presented through this tool is restricting those people's right to free speech.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoI don't know if I feel like that would hold up in court. Google's algorithm isn't helping individuals at Google construct speech, it's arguably collecting it's own data and presenting it's own results, merely according to guidelines it was taught or programmed with.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Google's algorithm isn't helping individuals at Google construct speech, it's arguably collecting it's own data and presenting it's own results Google's algorithm isn't a independent agency, its a tool created by humans for a human purpose.
- Kalium 11y agoThat it's meant to redact "untrue" information isn't relevant. It's very often used to redact inconvenient information, such as news stories about your bankruptcy or negative reviews of your business. RTBF does things well beyond its intention.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoIf that occurs, that is only through Google's negligent implementation of the law, and not through an issue with the law itself. Bearing in mind that Google itself is in charge of deciding what links meet the criteria to censor.
- Kalium 11y agoWhat, precisely, is negligent about Google's implementation of censorship? From where I'm sitting they're aggressively in compliance with the law. Some people have decided that since the law seems to be doing things it wasn't intended to, it's Google's fault.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoI'm saying the law clearly defines was does, and does not qualify. If Google is blocking sites that as you say, are things like negative reviews of your business, then Google is not following the RTBF law.
- Kalium 11y agoAll the person has to do is deem something irrelevant or inadequate and voila! Have you ever heard of a thing known as "due process"? Have you considered the possibility that laws may have effects other than those intended?
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoI mean, if you're willing to agree that Google is not trustworthy enough to make these sorts of determinations themselves, on that we can agree. The only real problem with RTBF law is that Google is allowed to decide, rather than a judge.