3 ms·
There's something missing from this: SoSerious made ad hominem attacks on DCurtis because that was the point - he was pointing out DCurtis' lack of tact and how
by potatolicious 17y ago
There's something missing from this: SoSerious made ad hominem attacks on DCurtis because that was the point - he was pointing out DCurtis' lack of tact and how his presumptuous tone in the end helped nobody (and got someone fired). The point to be made was to question DCurtis' character, ad hominem attacks are entirely expected.
What most people have against ad hominem attacks is where the character of the speaker is called into question in order to discredit a point that has no relation to it. I don't think I'm the only one who opposes this.
Some people need to have their character and human flaws called out - but not when it has no relations to the argument being made.
- billswift 17y agoAttacking someone's character are NOT ad hominem. Ad hominem is when you attack an argument BY attacking the person who made it, eg His argument is wrong because he is a conservative (which I see on HN fairly often).