3 ms·
They are a public good and a natural human right. No they aren't. Saying that is equivalent to saying that you would be justified in putting a gun to a chemis
by mindcrime 11y ago
They are a public good and a natural human right.
No they aren't. Saying that is equivalent to saying that you would be justified in putting a gun to a chemist's head and forcing him to make a drug for you even if he didn't want to. But there's no reason to say that your "right" to a drug trumps his right to be free from threat of violence and denial of agency.
What you're talking about is more of an entitlement than a right.
Holding people's health hostage is unacceptable whether you do it with a knife in an alley, or a capitalist health system.
Why exactly should I feel like society owes me health care that I can't pay for? Especially when the model involves a scenario where my getting health-care possibly involves using violence, or threat of violence, to make somebody else provide that care? How is that ethical?
- JulianMorrison 11y agoYeah, yeah, I've read Ayn Rand too, but she's wrong. Even from a selfish perspective, public health is so crammed with positive externalities it pays for itself. Nobody's going to force chemists to make drugs. Instead the way tax works is that you force everyone to pay a fraction of their productivity into a fund that gets spent paying the chemist to make drugs, the pharmacist to deliver them, etc. It's very similar to insurance except that it doesn't have the perverse motivation to deny you care, and it's compulsory because a civilized society values people not writhing in pain and dying from uncured curable disease more highly than losing a fraction of their time working for the state to prevent it.
- gknoy 11y agoJudging from most of my Facebook feed, it feels like a lot of people in this country do not value that more highly than miniscule taxes.