10 ms·
You’re partially right at least. It’s now a completely undisguised harassment campaign.
by robin_reala 11y ago
You’re partially right at least. It’s now a completely undisguised harassment campaign.
- Karunamon 11y agoYeah, no. People claiming "harassment!" absent evidence is not proof of said harassment existing, doubly so when the people shouting the loudest have a profit motive for its supposed existence. Also: It would be rather disingenuous to claim that gamergate are a bunch of harassers without acknowledging that prominent people within the movement have received things like syringes and knives in the mail... and been blackballed from the industry.. Kind of puts in perspective this "harassment", which at its worst, can be described as "people saying mean things on the internet". http://deepfreeze.it http://deepfreeze.it - also all public record.
- igreulich 11y agoPerception is reality. And it seems the perception is that Gahergate is a group of harrasors. You (not you personally) saying it is not will not change that perception. It seems to me that if you want Gamegate to be taken seriously (though I think it is way to late for that) Gamergate needs to start cleaning out it ranks. Which highlights the real issue. Gamergate has no central entity. So there are going to be people harrassing under the banner of Gamergate, and you can’t do anything about it. The name is tarnished, full stop. It will be almost impossible for Gamergate to do any good now, assuming it ever wanted to good!
- Karunamon 11y agoYou (not you personally) saying it is not will not change that perception. Perhaps, but correcting misinformation wherever its seen should be the goal of anyone connected with the movement. Perceptions can change. Gamers have been a marginalized group for pretty much as long as the hobby has existed, so this is nothing new. People lying about them, their hobby, making fun of them as losers and shut-ins and immature and criminals in training, this is all de rigeur. One more insult on the pile doesn't change much. >Gamergate needs to start cleaning out it ranks. How so? Other than shouting down harassers, I'm not sure what action you expect a bunch of people centered around a hashtag and an idea to take. >It will be almost impossible for Gamergate to do any good now I'd say they've done quite a lot of good already. Disclosure policies at multiple journalism outfits enacted, FTC rules on paid endorsements being clarified due largely in part to an emailing campaign, hundreds of thousands of dollars raised for various charities...
- Dirlewanger 11y ago>I'd say they've done quite a lot of good already. Absolutely, and the saddest part about all this is that entities with painfully overt agendas (The Verge/Vox, Ars Technica, etc.) were more than happy to report on all the negatives, and will still continue to, while reporting none of the good that's come out of it. Same with people on this site for the most part: they've completely made up their mind about what Gamergate stands for and will hear nothing else about it. Which is hilariously ironic given how much this site likes to tote itself as a well-educated bunch. Groupthink/hivemind tendencies are always the same for any community of humans.
- DanBC 11y agoCan you (or any pro-gamergaters) show me one site that you think counts as a pro gamergate site?
- Karunamon 11y agoHere's a few: http://deepfreeze.it http://deepfreeze.it (exhaustively sourced list of complaints against game journalists and information on the movement as a whole) http://techraptor.com http://techraptor.com (games news site, spawned in the wake of gamergate) http://escapistmagazine.com http://escapistmagazine.com (games news site, updated ethics policies after initial complaints, allows open discussion on the forums)
- DanBC 11y agoDeepFreeze.it repeats the lies about Zoe Quinn. http://www.deepfreeze.it/article.php?a=monster http://www.deepfreeze.it/article.php?a=monster > The overwhelming majority of their coverage consists solely of reprinting verbatim the anecdotal and often unverified accounts from controversial figures who directly profit from being considered targets of harassment — Zoe Quinn being a good example. > Often described as an indie developer, Quinn has produced very little aside from the low-effort, unpolished free text adventure Depression Quest. More notable about Quinn was the disproportionate attention she got from the gaming press despite her limited accomplishments, from journalists such as her financial backer Ben Kuchera of Polygon and her friend Patricia Hernandez of Kotaku. http://www.deepfreeze.it/article.php?a=unfair http://www.deepfreeze.it/article.php?a=unfair > Hernandez has also promoted two Kickstarters by GaymerX while being on friendly terms with the organization's president Toni Rocca and some of the other GaymerX staff. She has also given positive press, without disclosure, to her friends David Gallant and Zoe Quinn. http://www.deepfreeze.it/journo.php?j=nathan_grayson http://www.deepfreeze.it/journo.php?j=nathan_grayson > Positive coverage of Zoe Quinn in three articles, without disclosing their friendship and eventual affair. Later covered Quinn again, disclosing they "dated briefly", but not that he had previously financially supported her. Techraptor does the same. http://techraptor.net/content/zoe-quinn-lying-journalists http://techraptor.net/content/zoe-quinn-lying-journalists > One of the first things that seems quite possibly true about Zoe Quinn is the fact that she plays heavily into self-victimization. Now I will concede that I am not entirely knowledgeable about the psychology behind self-victimization, but what it is defined as makes it fairly easy to identify. > The most high profile example of this was Zoe Quinn’s claim that Wizardchan raided and doxxed (acquired and revealed personal info) her. That whole affair is best summed up here. Basically, the takeaway from that is that her accusations hold little if any merit at all. What is consistently seen throughout that is how easily she puts herself forward as a victim and asks for consolation from a variety of personalities and sites. Even if you only read the text surrounding the images of her tweets and other communications, you can see this. This is supposed to be an example of a site that doesn't promote and continue harassment? I can see why people think gamergate advocates are the worst kind of fucking scumbag.
- Torgo 11y agoGamergate doesn't actually have "ranks", it is a multi-homed, decentralized mob. That is the genius/horror of it. Welcome to the future of memetic warfare, it has already reached escape velocity from 4chan.
- mushtifaha 11y ago> The name is tarnished, full stop. You know what other names are tarnished? Liberals, Socialists, Democrats, Conservatives, Republicans, Christians, Muslims, ecologists, feminists, etc. Every sufficiently large movement has had its name dragged through the mud by its opposition. It's how things work. Gamergate is fine and continues to do good, whether the adversaries want to acknowledge it or not.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> People claiming "harassment!" absent evidence is not proof of said harassment existing Who said there's no evidence?
- mushtifaha 11y agoIt is being continuosly harassed by people who claim they are fighting harassment, that's for sure. But I don't think that such strategy is going to pay off. You can't just yell harassment as means to abuse people into submission. Many have tried similar tactics in the past and it never works in the long run.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> It is being continuosly harassed by people who claim they are fighting harassment, that's for sure. Harassed? Which members of gamergate have been forced out of their homes?
- BgSpnnrs 11y agoI think Mike Cernovich did after he got doxxed and attempted swatted
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoIf a few incidents by bad actors make a harassment campaign, what does that say for feminism with incidents such as donglegate.
- icebraining 11y agoKarunamon above, defending GG, says it started out as an harassment campaign. Is it wrong?
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoI'm sure there are a few civil rights movements that had some nasty issues when they started out. Do we judge based on where one came from or who one is now?
- icebraining 11y agoI think I was clear in that I wasn't talking about isolated incidents. comrh wrote "the beginning of the GG movement was mainly a force to harass people", and Karunamon - who has also been defending GG on this thread - agreed. If a civil rights movement had started for the purpose of doing unacceptable acts, I would definitively judge the people who chose to associate with it. (Of course, I'd excuse a lot from a civil rights movement that I wouldn't excuse from a movement dedicated to fighting bad gaming journalism - regardless of the merits of their claims.)
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>Karunamon - who has also been defending GG on this thread - agreed. I'm not sure why Karunamon agreed, but I largely passed on this point because that is an argument that would only distract from the overall point. I would assume Karunamon wanted to not get mired down in that point as well. From what I have seen, I would say that it was not founded for that purpose, but there have been bad actors who have been a part of it. >Of course, I'd excuse a lot from a civil rights movement that I wouldn't excuse from a movement dedicated to fighting bad gaming journalism What are some behaviors you would excuse from one but not the other?