3 ms·
How do these findings stack against the fact that violent crimes in the U.S. Have been trending downward for decades, while violent game and media sales have be
by dahart 11y ago
How do these findings stack against the fact that violent crimes in the U.S. Have been trending downward for decades, while violent game and media sales have been trending upwards? (And parental awareness and involvement have been trending upwards as well...)
https://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2012/crime-in-the-u.s.-2012/violent-crime/violent-crime https://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2012/...
http://videogames.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourceID=003627 http://videogames.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourceID=00...
- Ensorceled 11y agoViolent crime rates are affected by literally hundreds of factors. There can be dozens of factors pushing the rate down and few dozen less pushing the rate up with the end result being we have an overall reduction.
- dahart 11y agoYes! You're right. This is true. So... if the trend is down, and somehow games are a force for increase in tendencies, then something else is pushing down even faster than games are pushing it up. What might that be? And what evidence do we have that games are pushing it up at all?
- Ensorceled 11y agoThis study? That's my point, an overall trend in a statistic with multiple confounding variables says nothing at all about any specific variable. The study is either correct or flawed. The overall crime rate is NOT evidence against nor for the study.
- dahart 11y agoYeah, you're right. Sorry I'm not being clear & maybe sounding argumentative too. I'm really responding not to the study itself, and not to the direct conclusions they make, but to the suggestions and implications they leave open. The study says one thing, but the presentation says something else, and it is implying that this is a stepping stone to showing that violent games do affect the crime rate, and "negative outcomes" in general for children who play violent video games. I'm responding to this speculation. You're right that the overall crime rate doesn't say anything about this study, but it does say something about the implication they're trying to make in this press release, and the future work and courses of action they suggest in this study's conclusions.
- Ensorceled 11y agoAh, got it. Yeah, I hate that section of papers; "I've shown small, isolated result X. Perhaps this implies large, wildly extraordinarily speculative claim Y."
- mfoy_ 11y agoFirst off. The report links violence in video games to "increases in aggressive behavior, aggressive cognitions and aggressive affect, and decreases in prosocial behavior, empathy and sensitivity to aggression", NOT violent crimes. Secondly, (http://tylervigen.com/spurious-correlations http://tylervigen.com/spurious-correlations) just as correlation does not imply causation, a lack of correlation does not imply a lack of causation.
- dahart 11y agoYou're absolutely right, and FWIW, I'm perfectly clearly on the distinction between correlation and causation, or lack thereof. But tell me this: if they're not talking about violence, why do the words "violent", "violence" and "violently" occur 23 times in that 1-page summary? The root "aggress" occurs at less than half that rate. They spend a lot of time implying, suggesting, and speculating on links between "aggressive behavior" and "violent behavior." They were indeed careful to say the research doesn't support a conclusion about violence, however this summary is clearly written to induce the fear that the kind of aggression they're talking about and violent behaviors might be linked. “Rather, it is the accumulation of risk factors that tends to lead to aggressive *or violent behavior*. The research reviewed here demonstrates that violent video game use is one such risk factor.” “What researchers need to do now is conduct studies that look at the effects of video game play in people at risk for aggression *or violence* due to a combination of risk factors." (emphasis mine) 2- They raise "concerns" and conclude that action needs to be taken. The single conclusive action they suggest is one that I just provided evidence for already haven taken place on a large scale for many years. 3- Why are we talking about correlation and causation, when there's no correlation in the first place? That's the root of my question above. Yes, they're only claiming "aggression" and dancing around "violent" behavior, but they explicitly state more research need to be done to see if there are links. So, what is the concern, and why is there a need for research when in reality there is an overall inverse correlation between violent games and violent behavior? * edited for formatting
- dahart 11y agoAnd, BTW, let me add that as a concerned parent of children who's lives have been taken over by video games, I can accept and agree with the statement that when kids play video games, they get more "aggressive". Temporarily. The get more aggressive for a while. My kids and their friends play Super Smash Bros for a few hours, and then when they stop and go outside, they play fight for a while, they act out Super Smash Bros. I remember playing Wipeout XL in college and feeling like I was driving around on a race track when I'd get into a real car after that. My driving record, however, is spotless and I generally drive like a grandpa. Playing racing games made me temporarily fast & swervy. My kids playing fighting games makes them temporarily punchy. But overall, I haven't witnessed a permanent behavioral change. My concern with this report isn't whether it is right or wrong, I can believe that "aggressive behavior" increases when playing games, especially games that require aggressive behavior to win. My concern is with how it is being used, and what it is being used to imply. They spend a lot of time talking about violence to say they're not talking about violence directly, which just draws an implication between aggression and violence. They didn't, however, spend several paragraphs talking about how there might be a link between aggression after playing games and people becoming successful entrepreneurs, aggressive stock traders, world class athletes, or renowned scientists. Those are all occupations that require "aggressive" behavior and for which "aggressive" behavior is celebrated.