6 ms·
"The Air Force’s F-35A version of the aircraft and hold 182 rounds. It’s slated to be externally mounted on the Marine Corps’ F-35B jump-jet variant and the Nav
by protomyth 11y ago
"The Air Force’s F-35A version of the aircraft and hold 182 rounds. It’s slated to be externally mounted on the Marine Corps’ F-35B jump-jet variant and the Navy’s F-35C aircraft carrier version and hold 220 rounds"[1]
The F-35 has no hope of doing sustained CAS. It is another Air Force "drop your bombs and fire a few shots then run home" plane. An A-10 can keep insurgents away from your troops for a fair amount of time.
They should strip the Air Force of its CAS role and hand it back to the Army. Then the Air Force can concentrate on what it likes: strategic bombing and air dominance.
1) http://defensetech.org/2015/01/02/a-tale-of-two-gatling-guns-f-35-vs-a-10/ http://defensetech.org/2015/01/02/a-tale-of-two-gatling-guns...
- PythonicAlpha 11y agoMaybe you should also add, that the A-10 can carry 1,174 rounds for its front Gatling (from your link).
- protomyth 11y agoThe A-10 rounds are a tad bit more effective against insurgents hiding than the rounds shot by an F-35.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- chiph 11y agoIt actually does. The 30mm is a heavier bullet (even without taking the depleted-uranium core into account), and the case holds more powder, so it has a higher velocity. Both of which add up to more energy imparted into the target.
- danielvf 11y agoTake a cube, half the size of each edge, and the cube weighs one eighth as much. In this case, the 20% reduction in diameter, while keeping the same shape means the projectiles are less than half the size. In a counter-insurgency role, the A-10 fires roughly 65 13.3 ounce high explosive shells in one second. Roughly 54 pounds of high explosive shells per second. The F-35 is planned to fire 55 6.5 ounce projectiles per second. That's 22 pounds of shells per second. 54 lbs vs 22 lbs is a significant difference. Though, as others have said, it's the ammo capacity that is the major problem with the F-35's proposed gun. Only being able to make one or two guns runs before being out of ammunition precludes any kind of sustained ground support.
- PythonicAlpha 11y agoExactly. It is the same with artillery or tank ammunition -- a small increase in diameter makes a huge impact.
- Retric 11y agoIf you’re shooting tanks then sure it's a significant advantage, but when the target is a pickup truck with a machine gun mounted on the back you don't need that much penetrating power.
- protomyth 11y agoThere are walls and other obstacles in the field that a gun designed to shoot through a tank can go through. You do need that much penetrating power to make sure their hidey hole is not safe.
- Retric 11y agoThe A-10 was designed for an anti-tank role. So, I suspect there rounds are generally overkill. A smaller round than you might think can penetrate a brick/cinderblock wall. For hardened targets an Air-to-Surface missile can have a lot more penetrating power. In the end some compromise between the two is probably ideal. That said if you’re doing dedicated ground support I think you’re going to want a lot more round than an F-35 is designed for.
- PythonicAlpha 11y agoI am not sure, if you even need 25mmm in this particular case. I would say that with the right aiming even a machine gun will do it. But when you do not look at the penetrating power alone, but the blowing effect, than a bigger round can hold more explosives (of course, I don't know, if the A-10 Gatling cannon can also take explosive rounds instead of the armor breaking rounds). But of course the parallel poster is right: there are several things to penetrate -- particularly when partisans are heavily covered.
- 11y ago
- Gracana 11y agoThe GAU-12 fires 25x137 and the GAU-8 fires 30x173, so it's more than just a slightly larger diameter bullet: http://milpas.cc/rifles/ZFiles/Misc/MILITARY%20CARTRIDGE%20RELATIONSHIPS/MCRel3.jpg http://milpas.cc/rifles/ZFiles/Misc/MILITARY%20CARTRIDGE%20R... I didn't dig too deeply, but I found recoil force measurements... 4000lbf for the GAU-12 and 10000lbf for the GAU-8.
- tsotha 11y agoThe gun on the F-35 is basically pointless. They didn't even include it on the B and C versions. CAS from an F-35 is all about SDB.
- ckozlowski 11y agoThere's a lot more to CAS than simply how many bullets your gun has. In any case, it's often not the preferred weapon. Bullets are indiscriminate. Small, precision warheads are becoming more in favor because the safety margin is better. We've been seeing quite a bit in Afghanistan now where CAS is actually being performed by a B-1 carrying a SNIPER pod, sitting up at medium altitude with a large load of small precision bombs. But that shows you the type of environment Afghanistan is, where the Air Force can deploy high value assets like a B-1 to perform CAS, because their anti-air threat is non-existent. The Air Force is not developing the F-35 to fight insurgents, they're deploying it to fight a well equipped, conventional force that will have multiple layers of sophisticated weapons. They'll do everything they can to soften these up before the strike aircraft go in. But there /will/ be some that remain, and its in this environment, that the F-35 needs to survive. In the low-threat environment against insurgents, you can do that job just as well as the A-10 with the A-29 as the article states, for ever cheaper. This is the conclusion that the Air Force has come to, and that's why they're retiring the A-10.
- protomyth 11y agoMy cousin has related stories of the A-10 watching over him and his troops. Bullets most definitely were the main item related. The A-10's ability to stay above his group and fire a couple of rounds every so often allow them to sleep. The F-35 or B-1 is not going to do that. Drones don't currently do that. The goal is to safeguard the troops and bullets work very well. The Air Force hates CAS and will say anything to get out of it. The fact that a modern version of the A-10 has not been developed (the F-35 is not a modern version) says everything about the Air Force's direction.