3 ms·
Mankind has been at war for most of its existence. Only after WW2 and the development of nuclear weapons has war become much too risky due to MAD and has made d
by pm90 11y ago
Mankind has been at war for most of its existence. Only after WW2 and the development of nuclear weapons has war become much too risky due to MAD and has made diplomacy a much more viable option....for the more powerful nations. Meanwhile, we still have civil war in Syria, unrest in Africa etc.
Once we colonize other worlds and space travel becomes more feasible, earth will become less valuable: the powers that be can relocate to another planet and just fight their proxy wars on earth.
- talmand 11y agoMankind has always been at war with itself over resources. The introduction of nuclear weapons only removed the option of total war from the table, all the other regular warfare standards are still in play.
- lukifer 11y agoThe reality is that war is an effective means of population equilibrium, and it's no coincidence that its' enthusiasts skew heavily male. Genetically speaking, it offers a good deal: eliminate competitor males, and if you survive, your mating opportunities statistically improve after the war is over (and that's without mentioning the horrid connection between war and mass rape in ancient warfare, and still sometimes today). Ironically enough, I think these violent "selfish gene" urges have been co-opted into (relatively) less deadly forms of war by sociopaths who seek economic domination and control (typically using the recursive logic of game theory; after all, they're just keeping up with the other sociopaths). I wish I could remember the source, but I've read that conquest and colonionism is so expensive that it tends to be net-neutral even after extracting the resources of the vanquished; however, it is an extremely effective way to transfer wealth internally between powers on the victor's side. Given the perverse incentives at work, the only way to reduce war is to pro-actively wage peace, from every angle: deepen economic interdependence, extend the circle of empathy through culture, and perhaps most importantly, continue to inter-breed across every geographic and ethnic divide.
- talmand 11y agoWell, war is almost always about resources in one way or another. Excellent points you make. As for your last point, I quote a movie that's a favorite of mine, Bulworth: Sen. Jay Billington Bulworth: "All we need is a voluntary, free-spirited, open-ended program of procreative racial deconstruction. Everybody just gotta keep fuckin' everybody 'til they're all the same color." Indeed.
- jcranmer 11y agoActually, mankind has probably not been at war for most of its existence. Homo sapiens comes into existence ~200kya. By contrast, there is no evidence of warfare for most of the Paleolithic, and the first unambiguous evidence only comes ~10-12kya. In other words, the development of warfare is only roughly contemporaneous with the development of agriculture and sedentarism.
- at-fates-hands 11y agoThe avoidance of war was probably due to the low population numbers and the ability of groups of hunter/gatherers to avoid each other. As the population grew and humans came into more frequent contact with each other, warfare was a natural by-product of the increased contact between groups.
- s_kilk 11y agoAgriculture also brought in a massive change in how humans regarded territory. For hunter-gatherer societies there was basically no impulse to fight over territory. Everything they needed could be foraged, and the things they foraged were plentiful. Once we switched from foraging in a bountiful nature to scrounging a meager living from the dirt, defending that dirt or seizing more of it became a much bigger thing.
- tosseraccount 11y agoDo you have any evidence that hunter gatherer societies have "basically no impulse to fight over territory"?
- mrec 11y ago> For hunter-gatherer societies there was basically no impulse to fight over territory I'd dispute that. Don't confuse sparse population density with "bountiful nature"; hunter-gatherer economies are severely limited in that they can only sustainably forage as much as the environment can regenerate. The fact that they're territory-limited rather than labour-limited gives ample incentive to fight over territory, and also explains the popular factoid that these societies had vastly more leisure time than we do.