2 ms·
Why are flat structures necessarily project based? I'm sorry to appear argumentative, but this is an area where we as tech workers have a great opportunity to
by icebraining 11y ago
Why are flat structures necessarily project based?
I'm sorry to appear argumentative, but this is an area where we as tech workers have a great opportunity to explore alternatives to the dominant system of command-and-control, since we have small companies which are already tasked with trying new stuff, and what I'm seeing is blanket rejection based on a few (often misguided and naive) tries.
I'm not an expert either, but I've seen many small organizations as a grew up (specifically, theatre groups), and while they had project (plays) based distribution of tasks, some also managed the other stuff (like finances and requests of grants) without creating an hierarchy or putting those people in any way in charge.
- Spooky23 11y agoIMO, the project-based nature of a flat org is essential because the project is a unifying mission with regular updates and well-understood outcomes (project milestones). Small orgs are different because motivated people can self-organize. A small theatre company or neighborhood block party committee can self organize because the core cadre of a half dozen people take care of the finances, grants, etc. Even in those cases, someone is at least nominally in charge -- an individual needs to sign checks, apply for grants, hold the cash, etc. I've lived this at least a dozen times, in a mid/late stage startup, F500 company, and sprawling government bureaucracy. The story is always the same. New business units emerge with a guy in charge and a nimble team of <10 people. They achieve success and grow. Problems start around 10-15 people because folks are focused and cannot productively communicate across the group. Leaders emerge and work out differences. The next point of resistance in around 25-30 people -- the lack of explicit authority undermines the emergent leaders. Everything breaks at 40-50 people unless there is an established chain of command. There may be a way to tweak these things and make it work, but it takes special skills/knowledge/instincts that aren't obvious to people. Special things are hard to repeat, and business relies on repeatable process. IMO, there are a couple of ways that flat orgs can work. The most obvious is where the work is delivering unkilled/skilled tasks. A plumbing company has a dispatcher who sends out plumbers. A consulting company has salesmen called Vice Presidents, Project Managers and dispatchers. No hierarchy. I think the other type of org is a co-op type arrangement. Coops have some hierarchy, but the power structure is elected vs. appointed which changes the dynamic.