3 ms·
That only works when you have a tiny number of flights at a handful of locations are willing to spend through the roof. It would never scale. Their largest inte
by jonknee 17y ago
That only works when you have a tiny number of flights at a handful of locations are willing to spend through the roof. It would never scale. Their largest international airport is tiny by US size--it wouldn't even make the top 20. And that's just the US.
Not to mention that the US public would never put up with it.
Update: this puts it into perspective--El Al (the largest and most well known Israeli airline) operates only 37 planes which would make it the size of a small regional airline in the states. Allegiant Air is unheard of to much of the US and operates 49 jets. Delta has a cool 449 and flies to more countries than El Al has flights per day. Ben Gurion International Airport, the airport mentioned and the largest in Israel, is roughly the size of Kansas City International Airport. There's simply not a valid comparison.
- pyre 17y agoWhat about the isolation of the suspected luggage in a bomb-proof area or container? All that would seem to require is investment in the containers and/or blast-proof shell. Why instead is the 'best idea' to try and evacuate a bustling airport terminal with 100's or 1000's of people?
- jonknee 17y agoThe part that wouldn't scale and that we would never put up with is the personal interrogations, highly armed guards covering entry points and all the searches. Go ahead and put some blast containers in place, but it would likely be a waste since there are so few evacuations.
- pyre 17y agoIf these airports handle so much traffic that these methods won't scale than how in the world is "evacuate the entire airport" even seriously considered as a solution to any problem?
- jonknee 17y agoIt's much more work to have half hour interviews with every passenger than it is to evacuate a terminal every couple years.
- kareemm 17y agoDid you even read the original article? It's a goal to move passengers from parking lot to gate in 25 minutes. Half-hour interviews aren't a part of the process.
- jonknee 17y agoPerhaps if you're a local it's quick. But they also recommended to show up three hours early for a reason... Long interrogations are quite common. If you fit a profile they will drill you like you have Osama on speed dial. This was a puff piece for how awesome El Al is, but the reality is their method only works because of the small number of passengers (and their willingness to accept racism). http://www.elal.co.il/ELAL/English/AllAboutYourFlight/AtTheAirport/CheckInTimes.htm http://www.elal.co.il/ELAL/English/AllAboutYourFlight/AtTheA...
- kareemm 17y agoBut they also recommended to show up three hours early for a reason. US check-in times for int'l flights are 2h. I'd rather show up 3h early and feel safe than 2h and feel like security is a joke. If you fit a profile they will drill you like you have Osama on speed dial. This was a puff piece for how awesome El Al is, but the reality is their method only works because of the small number of passengers (and their willingness to accept racism). First, nobody is free of racial bias. This bias will leak into the decisions we all make, everyday. Take this test and let me know how it turns out: https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/Launch?study=/user/edu.. https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/Launch?study=/user/edu.... That said, the Israelis use behavioral profiling, not racial profiling. There's no need to dismiss a security system that the US can learn from and improve by dropping the "R" bomb.
- 17y ago
- waterlesscloud 17y agoOf course, there are "personal interrogations" in US airports today. They're just "random", but they most assuredly exist.