5 ms·
Wow, people are really missing the big picture. These are great developments towards reducing environmental damage, increase animal welfare and long term increa
by wodenokoto 11y ago
Wow, people are really missing the big picture. These are great developments towards reducing environmental damage, increase animal welfare and long term increase health (as we can much better tweak nutritional content of meat, when we construct it ourselves)
- tbrownaw 11y agolong term increase health (as we can much better tweak nutritional content of meat, when we construct it ourselves) I'd be a bit concerned about this, with how the guidelines keep changing.
- omginternets 11y ago>as we can much better tweak nutritional content of meat, when we construct it ourselves Hmm, I heard something vaguely familiar not so long ago... Have people already forgotten trans-fats? To call meat, let alone nutrition, complex is an understatement that borders on comical. To think the first hundred iterations of artificial meat will be anything short of carcinogenic strikes me as an opinion ill-informed by history.
- eimai134 11y agoThose are two entirely different things. This type of fake meat is plant-based. Trans fats are highly uncommon in nature, and the hydrogenation process used to create them is completely different from what goes into making fake meats.
- omginternets 11y ago>and the hydrogenation process used to create them is completely different from what goes into making fake meats. And this is completely missing the point, which is that the processes used to make fake meat are significantly different from those encountered in nature, and therefore likely to introduce side-effects.
- CamperBob2 11y agoAs somebody pointed out in a comment on another story, your CPU executed about a dozen instructions while the light from your monitor traveled to reach your eyes. So I think we can make meat.
- nulltype 11y agoOf course we can, but could we manufacture pure solid hubris?
- CamperBob2 11y agoI think that's already pretty much nailed.
- paulojreis 11y agoOh, of course. Processing power and extensive computation solves everything, right?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 11y ago>Your CPU executed about a dozen instructions while the light from your monitor traveled to reach your eyes. So I think we can make meat. Argument from non sequitur?
- CamperBob2 11y agoArgument from "When there's a will, and a lot of money, there's a way."
- omginternets 11y agoSo an argument on faith, then? That's not any better.
- 11y ago
- coldtea 11y agoWe don't "construct it ourselves" and nobody that does it is concerned with "reducing environmental damage", "increase animal welfare" or "long term health increase" (even if they pay lip service to these). Mega-corporations do the construction (as opposed to interest-less impartial scientists), and they do it to maximize shareholder profit. History the world over has shown that they'd sell radioactive heroin to kids if they could get away with it and it had nice margins. Same way they sold us tobacco, trans fats, HFCS, all kinds of BS (but higher margin) low quality food ingredients, nutricionally attrocious and health-damaging snacks, tasteless and unhealthy food substitutes to increase their margins, etc.
- fulafel 11y agoInterest-ed scientists are concerned with those things and are looking for (or founding) organizations to facilitate the research, be it megacorporations or academic funding/institutions or vc.
- coldtea 11y agoThe history of the modern processed foods industry doesn't give much credibility to the idea that concerned scientists can or will make a difference "from the inside". The profit margins and interests of mega-corps trump the objections or motives of any "concerned scientist" working there. Besides, it's the management's way or the highway, there are no irreplacable "star" scientists, so that their personal beliefs would made much of a difference. For academic and third party instutitions yes, but those don't produce or dictate what we eat, and mega-corps can mix and match whatever is more profitable from their research, or ignore it entirely (well, unless regulated to do otherwise, and even so they'll use every loophole they can, if unhealthy cheapo stuff gives higher margins. It's not as the general public -- ignoring upper/middle class organic buyers and such -- is very discerning).
- fulafel 11y agoThey're not "concerned scientists working from the inside" anymore when they're making a difference, hence your claim is perhaps valid on its face but misleading! After that they become "megacorporations chasing after advertising-led demand of fake meat" from the cynic's POV.
- Grue3 11y ago>increase animal welfare More like, all domesticated meat animals will go extinct since they're not needed anymore and they can't survive in the wild.
- eimai134 11y agoThere are a number of preserves for farm animals, and many people have pigs, chickens, goats, and cows simply as pets. The number of these animals in existence will decrease, but they will still be around, just happy and healthier. We don't have to confine, torture and kill animals to prevent them from going extinct!
- noondip 11y ago> More like, all domesticated meat animals will go extinct since they're not needed anymore and they can't survive in the wild. That's a gross oversimplification which neglects to acknowledge the fact modern, industrial-scale animal agriculture is the leading cause of species extinction, ocean dead zones, water pollution, and habitat destruction.