3 ms·
Somehow I don't remember reading about the "hospital room showdown" in the past. Incredibly fascinating to read about the legal gymnastics performed by G.W. and
by zaroth 11y ago
Somehow I don't remember reading about the "hospital room showdown" in the past. Incredibly fascinating to read about the legal gymnastics performed by G.W. and Cheney's lawyer, and exactly when and where the words "collect" and "acquire" got their peculiar meanings. Impressive how much Ashcroft and Yoo were channeling Nixon a la "When the President does it, it is not illegal." The Executive branch "displacing" Federal law is not the separation of powers I remember learning as a kid. Is there any chance that theory could ever actually see scrutiny at the Supreme Court?!
Nice to know there was at least someone at Justice finally ready to walk out based on NSA bulk collecting email and phone records. But how exactly was the program "curbed" in order to avert the threat of "mass walkouts"? Is it not safe to assume that bulk meta-data collection of email, phone, payments, license plates, facial recognition, phone triangulation, etc. persist and in fact are only mounting in coverage, accuracy, and post-processing?
I suppose the last territory to cover is beam-forming microphones with high accuracy far-field voice recognition in crowded environments. The technology certainly exists in the lab at this point, I would assume only a few years ago from mass-deployment and collection. Of course, relax, conversations are only "acquired" when they searched, so our leaders can happily testify that American's every outside conversation isn't actually being "collected" in full searchable text form in Utah.
- Natsu 11y agoI remember it very clearly because it was perhaps the only time that most techies were in support of Ashcroft's actions.
- pdkl95 11y agoFrontline covered the "hospital room showdown" in their documentary they published last year, "United States Of Secrets"[1]. Their web video player has a bookmark called "Concerns at the Justice Department" for the part about the "showdown", though the entire video (and part 2!) is worth watching. [1] http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/united-states-of-secrets/#united-states-of-secrets-%28part-one%29 http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/united-states-of-sec...