4 ms·
> Gurgaon, however, lacks important infrastructure, especially in areas such as sewage and electricity where the optimal scale exceeds that of most builders. I
by ams6110 11y ago
> Gurgaon, however, lacks important infrastructure, especially in areas such as sewage and electricity where the optimal scale exceeds that of most builders.
I'm not sure I see how this explanation makes sense. How can a bunch of bumbling elected city councils manage to construct adequate water and sewer works, and private builders who actually know what they are doing cannot.
- digi_owl 11y agoCould be similar to Dubai, where i think they had problems with buildings being erected faster than the infrastructure could be expanded to handle them. End result were skyscrapers that had to get their sewage removed by truck each day, etc.
- HarryHirsch 11y agoAnd this, ladies and gentlemen, is why planning permission was invented. Your proposed subdivision exceeds capacity of existing roads? Sorry, can't build here, because you can't make bank while unloading your externalities on the town council or the county. You want to build in a floodplain? Sorry dude, can't have that, it will flood, and everyone living there is suddenly a burden on the public purse because their savings vehicle has just been drowned.
- bcoates 11y agoYou want to not let people build skyscrapers to protect the egos of city authorities that can't build a sewage system that would meet the western standards of 100 years ago? Dubai has problems, but tall buildings aren't one of them.
- omegaworks 11y agoIt's mostly to do with power and coordination. The private sector is great at meeting needs very efficiently, but the market needs to be shaped in the right way to make sure they don't burn the world to make your iced tea a little sweeter :)
- zhte415 11y ago> How can a bunch of bumbling elected city councils manage to construct adequate water and sewer works, and private builders who actually know what they are doing cannot. Because they know what they're doing. Tragedy of the Commons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons
- bane 11y agoIt's like roads. Private builders enter into agreements all the time to enter into deals with local governments where they'll expand roads or whatever right around where they're developing. If you get lucky you'll have a contiguous string of adjacent developers and you'll end up with a nice road for a few miles. If you're unlucky, you'll end up with 4 lane divided road-farm road-4 lane divided road-farm road, off and on for miles and miles and it's pretty much the worst. Private developers don't have incentive to build a national highway system, they'll just build whatever is the minimum necessary that figures into their profit model.
- HarryHirsch 11y agoPrivate developers will build whatever people want, which sometimes is completely unlike what people need. Sometime back, there was a recently built over-55 community discussed here. It looked just like your generic subdivision. One wonders how much misery will be there 20 years from now. Wide roads without sidewalks are not good for people with low mobility and vision problems, and there is no adequate hospital and nursing services around, not even a food store within close distance. The future in that development will be fun to watch.
- bane 11y ago> Private developers will build whatever people want I think maybe a better way to think of it is that developers will build whatever makes them money -- a good enough proxy for wants in many cases, but not for all.