3 ms·
If the alternative is soap operas or Farmville and $0/hour, why isn't $2.50/hour "fair"? Not every casual, part-time, voluntary, done-at-your-own-pace-on-your-
by gojomo 17y ago
If the alternative is soap operas or Farmville and $0/hour, why isn't $2.50/hour "fair"?
Not every casual, part-time, voluntary, done-at-your-own-pace-on-your-own-terms activity should have to pay a "living" wage. That sort of standard doesn't "protect" people -- it destroys potential.
"Exploitation" is not a matter of first-world absolute watermarks (like a statutory minimum wage) of the value of people's time. It's a matter of what their other options are. If they have to work for $2.50/hour or starve, that could be a problem. If they choose to work for $2.50/hour rather than watch TV, then something other than exploitation is happening. (And besides the immediate but less-than-minimum-wage benefits, the person could also be building knowledge and skills towards an eventual higher-paid job.)
And if you only prohibit American workers from taking such casual voluntary work, why is it better for the $2.50 to go overseas?
- adamhowell 17y agoYour classification of what people would do if it weren't for the grace of Cha-Cha paying them is offensive -- "soap operas", "Farmville", "watch TV". It's easier for you to make your argument if you color these people as "do nothings" who are lucky to get whatever work is offered to them. If businesses should be able to pay certain people living wages and others whatever they work for, should McD's pay high school kids $2.50 and single moms more? Also, the work I do is at my own pace, does that mean my company should pay me less since I'm not being forced to produce? The simple fact that it's work done from home doesn't mean the rules that regular businesses must follow need not apply. Also, $2.50/hr overseas isn't $2.50/hr, it's whatever the conversion rate is. That's why that conversation is much more complicated. And I'm not a protectionist, so I have no problem with the notion of offshoring.
- gojomo 17y agoYou're straining to take offense, and so imagining slights against these people that weren't present or intended. Really, many of the people doing online piecework, like Cha-Cha answers or MTurk tasks, aren't even looking for a real clock-in job. They're just engaged in a diversion, and happy to be making a little on the side. If they weren't doing the piecework, they would be Facebooking, IM'ing, TV-watching, gaming -- something else they can do in dribs and drabs at home. In fact, they may be doing all those things simultaneously! If your preferred crackdown was enacted -- abolishing their current arrangement -- many wouldn't even look for one of your "fair" regulated minimum-wage jobs, clocking in at some office or fast-food-joint. I respect them to make their own decisions. You "color these people" as if they were helpless victims "who let themselves be taken advantage of" and "aren't using the same judgement and resources to make their decisions as those who know better". That's more denigratory to voluntary at-home pieceworkers than anything I've said.