4 ms·
> I'll give you one thing - financial planning education in the US is absolutely awful and continues to fail millions of people every year. It's not just finan
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
> I'll give you one thing - financial planning education in the US is absolutely awful and continues to fail millions of people every year.
It's not just financial planning education -- it's financial planning policy.
Almost every policy we have is described as progressive, but isn't, and acts to discourage saving.
We have a graduated income tax. Where do the brackets start? ~$9000. That'll teach those fat cats making $15,000/year. And Richie Rich over there making over ~$37,000 will have to pay even more again -- even though the minimum wage fat cats were already paying the same marginal rate as investment bankers pay on capital gains. And the investment bankers don't pay into social security but you pay the full rate starting from dollar zero. Which money you won't get back unless you live long enough, can't dip into for emergencies (so emergencies get paid with high interest debt rather than reduced savings), and statistically will pay out less than investing the same money in an index fund.
But that's not the half of it. The thing that really gets you is all the programs designed to "help" you. If these programs were unconditional (i.e. not tied to income/savings) then they might actually do this, but they aren't. And the thresholds are low.
So two things happen. First you want to send your kids to college. Did you have some money saved up? We'll take that right out of your financial aid package thankyouverymuch, that'll teach you to save money. Same thing if you have to change careers and go back to school yourself. Then you realize that the amount of money you're making isn't going to cut it and look around for ways to make more -- which is where you get hit by the train.
They call it progressive because people who make more money are supposed to pay more. But they never bother to tell you "more money than what" -- and the number is less than minimum wage. You work part time stocking shelves at the Walmart and you get government subsidies for food, housing, healthcare, etc. You bust your hump going to night school for three years so you can get a $38,000/year job as assistant to the regional manager and the subsidies evaporate... leaving you pretty much back where you started, only now you have student loans. But try to save something for retirement, would you?