4 ms·
> Those six years staying in school getting your undergraduate and graduate degrees, will make a huge difference in the rest of your life Conversely, six years
by nailer 11y ago
> Those six years staying in school getting your undergraduate and graduate degrees, will make a huge difference in the rest of your life
Conversely, six years of actual experience mean you'll be able to apply for senior jobs that pay well, and you'll have a fun, debt-free 20s.
- jedberg 11y agoThis is very true of graduate school vs not, but I'm not so sure about undergrad. A few points: I stopped going to school after undergrad and started working, while most of my friends went and did grad school. When they graduated I was already ahead of the salaries they were being offered and had 5 years of experience. I'd also been earning twice as much as them for those five years and had considerable savings. Also, I've hired people who never went to college. They were fairly qualified but what I found was odd gaps in their knowledge. They could write good code but then didn't know anything about say bayesian probability, so I would have to design the software for them which they could then code. They could certainly learn about bayesian probability, but the problem was they didn't even know it existed so they were pursuing a terrible solution to the problem that had a well known and simpler solution, until someone who went to college came and informed them. Perhaps the same applies to those who went to grad school, but I've never found that to be the case in practice.
- something123 11y ago5 years of grad school implies a PhD - in which case they should be hyper specialize in some field. Sounds like your friends just chose the wrong subject to pursue a PhD in. Normally you're supposed to end up being one of the top 20 experts in a very narrow field of study. In generally this doesn't bear out in computer science (which I still think is barely qualified to be a department)
- jedberg 11y agoThey are in fact top experts in their fields (1/2 were computer science and the other 1/2 were chemistry). But even being the top in your field doesn't outweigh 5 years of experience.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- learc83 11y agoMaybe for their first jobs in industry. But assuming they aren't in academia, I'm betting a PhD in an in-demand CS field will be making a lot more than someone with a BS and 5 extra years experience in a few years. Not to mention that for the type of jobs that require a PhD, the 5 years it takes is 5 years of relevant experience. And there are many jobs that are effectively closed to people without PhDs regardless of how much experience they have.
- FLUX-YOU 11y ago> They were fairly qualified but what I found was odd gaps in their knowledge. As long as everyone knows that would be considered an odd gap in knowledge, you can prepare for that faster and cheaper than college (if not faster, it's certainly more cost-efficient). I could study endlessly worrying about knowledge gaps that would be an easy solution to a problem I currently have. There is value in splitting up the knowledge burden of solving problems. You can go wide, they can go deep. I say this with no knowledge of what bayesian probability is because I've never studied it!
- learc83 11y agoTo fill in all these gaps you'd need the equivalent of a 4 year CS degree. I say this as someone who worked as a software engineer for about 5 years before going back for my degree. You spend most of a CS degree studying the theory and techniques developed over the last 60+ years. These techniques are incredibly useful time and again. It's the difference between spending a month trying to solve a problem or realizing the problem is actually just a version of a graph theory problem that was solved 50 years ago. There are many positions in the field that can be filled by people without degrees. But there are also many that need someone who knows the theory and history. That's not to say that there aren't rare individuals who learn all this through self study, but they are rare.
- gozo 11y ago"They were fairly qualified but what I found was odd gaps in their knowledge." This very much goes both ways. A lot of recent college graduates lack practical software engineering experience, has overlooked the importance of related fields[0] and tend to be stuck in this examination mindset of individual correctness. [0] Like networking, security and operations.
- michaelt 11y agoDepends if the jobs you can get offer experience that will take you where you want to go. In some companies it might be possible to start out in the mail room and end up as the CEO. But if you spend six years in the mail room and you're still in the mail room, you're probably not at that type of company.
- halflings 11y agoI unfortunately don't remember where I heard this (maybe in the Freakonomics episode "Is college really worth it?" [1]), but 6 years of college clearly beat 6 years of experience. Also: getting 6 years of relevant work experience is (way) harder if you don't have a college degree in the first place... The famous "you need professional experience to get a job, you need a job to get professional experience". [1] http://freakonomics.com/2012/07/30/freakonomics-goes-to-college-part-1-a-new-freakonomics-radio-podcast/ http://freakonomics.com/2012/07/30/freakonomics-goes-to-coll...
- dagw 11y agoI initially dropped out of university after a year and started to work (went back to university a few years later). The jobs I was offered with 4 years of experience and just a high school diploma sucked in comparison to the jobs I got offered once I had 4 years of university and a degree under my belt.
- vcarl 11y agoI dropped out of university after a year and did a startup for 2 years. The jobs I've been offered since parting ways with the startup have been as good or better than my peers who went the traditional route. I think the takeaway is that, in certain fields and certain jobs, it's possible to get enough experience to be qualified for high quality jobs without a degree if you're willing to put in the effort. There's no "good job please" shortcut, but a degree isn't necessarily a prerequisite now.
- cthalupa 11y agoFor more anecdotal data points: I did not go to college. My first full time job was 3 years as what was basically help desk, with a bit of systems administration work thrown in. It did not pay particularly well, but it was still around the level that a lot of people with "normal" (none-STEM/Medical/etc type) degrees start at. After I got bored of it, I did some random consulting/contract work for various companies. A connection I met at one of those got me a job working for a company that would eventually wind up being purchased by IBM. At that place I was making as much as most of the people I went to high school with that were graduating with engineering degrees around that time and getting started in the industry. My next place of employment after a few years at that company put my salary range into a level that basically none of my peers from high school are at, including ones that have STEM degrees and law degrees. The couple that went on to become doctors are just now finishing up their residencies and will probably be beating me soon. One of my good friends from school followed a pretty similar path as me, and has an excellent job as a security engineer for a fortune 10 company without a degree. Networking + ability will help a lot in making up for not having a degree.
- gozo 11y ago
- IndianAstronaut 11y agoPeople who keep touting the benefits of a college degree keep forgetting the cost of a degree.