2 ms·
While it's blindingly obvious that the current monolithic pyramid schemes used to move money from the young to the old will have to disappear I have some news
by barrkel 11y ago
While it's blindingly obvious that the current monolithic pyramid schemes used to move money from the young to the old will have to disappear
I have some news for you - saving up now to pay for your retirement is also a transfer from young people to old people. The primary difference vs a tax and spend mechanism is that poor people suffer far more under a savings-based scheme, because they typically live hand to mouth and savings, if any, are for emergencies, not retirement.
Look at this way: if we're not going to euthanize old people, then they need to be supported somehow. In practical terms, that means a certain proportion of current production needs to be diverted to sustaining these old people. Whether this production is triggered by taxing or savings doesn't really make a difference to the physical distribution of stuff; a certain proportion of production will need to be diverted away from younger people and towards older people. It's either that or kill all the old people. And yes, this reduction in supply of stuff for younger people will also push up prices for younger people. In fact, the more savings older people have, the more expensive stuff is going to be for younger people in the future.
The primary benefit of the savings approach vs the taxing approach is that high-income people are much better off, and low-income people suffer far more. If that is indeed a benefit.