3 ms·
I don't disagree that you would want to have a rough idea of what migrating off of DynamoDB would require but wouldn't the easier step be using redundancy acros
by acdha 11y ago
I don't disagree that you would want to have a rough idea of what migrating off of DynamoDB would require but wouldn't the easier step be using redundancy across regions first? Most of the sites which have suffered downtime due to AWS outages have been operating in only a single region (or even AZ!) and adding the extra level isolation is usually going to be a lot easier than dealing with multiple vendors or having to maintain more of your infrastructure directly.
- speleding 11y agoIn this case AWS sign in is down (perhaps it depends on Dynamo), so redundancy across regions can only help you if fail over is fully automatic which has it's own problems (split brain syndrome...)
- acdha 11y agoAWS sign-in appears to be working but in general it's true that you need some sort of automatic failover. However, isn't that true for every option other than accepting downtime? It doesn't seem like an AWS-specific challenge other except at the implementation level.
- sitharus 11y agoOne of the first things Amazon tell you about AWS is the API is king - the console is hosted in us-east-1 but the API is hosted in each region independently. You don't need automatic failover, but you do need your own scripts to talk to the AWS API. The whole point of AWS is automation.
- zurn 11y agoThere are many high profile companies down (airbnb, IMDb, tinder, ...) so apparently this is not so straightforward.
- peterjancelis 11y agoI don't see airbnb or IMDB being down. If there's some advice on what small time apps (like mine) can do to get thing up again sooner, please let me know.
- cguess 11y agoExplains the weird 500's i was getting when trying to do a review this morning.
- gshx 11y agoRunning multi-region services has associated costs. It's also non-trivial engineering effort to convert most services to a multi-region setup. It's definitely worth the investment though. Another option is to run multi-region on the same provider (like AWS) without using proprietary services like DynamoDb but maybe something similar like Cassandra.