3 ms·
I find it highly unlikely they'd make much impact outdoors. 1 million cubic feet/hour is 16,666CFM. Wikipedia says a Manhattan city block is 264 by 900 feet. So
by MichaelGG 11y ago
I find it highly unlikely they'd make much impact outdoors. 1 million cubic feet/hour is 16,666CFM. Wikipedia says a Manhattan city block is 264 by 900 feet. So even if we assume 10' ceiling (so 2.3M CuFt) and little airflow, we'd still need several of these towers to clean it. Except outdoors are higher than 10 feet, and even light wind (avg in NY is 9MPH) will replace the air several times an hour.
More realistic are small filters like this one[1] where you have a relatively limited semi-enclosed space the air flows around. So perhaps in, say, small pavilions and seating areas in a park or something, it might be slightly useful if the surrounding area is rather polluted. But sticking a few in a "filthy rich neighborhood" isn't gonna accomplish much (apart from making money or making people feel smug).
Maybe on a city-scale, using real industrial-strength devices all over would work. But one would assume that cities with smog issues must have already looked at filtering systems and there must be some serious limitation or they'd be deployed already.
1: https://www.techinasia.com/outdoor-air-purifier-wait-bus-40-smoggy/ https://www.techinasia.com/outdoor-air-purifier-wait-bus-40-...
- zo1 11y agoBut if we're moving on to "industrial-strength devices" on a "city-scale", then we might as well mandate their installation near the producers of the unclean air that we're trying to clean. I.e. Make an industrial-strength version of this, and stick it on say a coal power plant's cooling tower. I'd imagine you'd get far more bang for your buck due to the efficiency gains of not having to "clean" almost-clean air.
- akiselev 11y agoI don't think there exists a coal plant in the developed world that isn't already using this technology. Without these particulate filters, a wide swath of area around each coal plant would be entirely uninhabitable by modern standards.