27 ms·
Though this evens out a lot when you have many farms with some distance between them. Many coal and nuclear plants are actually quite good at load following (a
by fulafel 11y ago
Though this evens out a lot when you have many farms with some distance between them.
Many coal and nuclear plants are actually quite good at load following (at least in France and Germany it's common to run nukes in this mode). The units are quite big so they don't have to do that many % per hour in order to keep up with a wind park.
- Animats 11y ago"Though this evens out a lot when you have many farms with some distance between them." Unfortunately, it doesn't. The big grids such as CAISO (all of California, with wind farms over a range of 500 miles) and PJM (Ohio to the Atlantic Ocean) still routinely see 4:1 variations over the course of a day. Here's today's CAISO data: Max wind generation: 1350 MW, at 1 AM. Min wind generation: 186MW, at 5 PM.[1] This sucks. At least with solar, you get max output and max air conditioning load at the same time. Getting max wind generation at 1 AM is not too helpful. However, the California Water Project, which is a big power buyer for pumping water uphill, profitably buys late-night cheap power for pumping, then lets water back down through turbines during high-load periods. So some of the big reservoirs double as pumped storage. Batteries would help. It will take a lot of them. At least 300,000 Tesla Powerwall battery packs would be required to load balance that variation in wind. That's about a billion dollars, which is not unreasonable. When we see wind farms starting to buy batteries in bulk, it will be clear this is working. But the amount of battery required for reliability is higher than the amount required for improved profitability. Something has to be able to provide power when the wind is calm for a few days, which happens. [1] http://content.caiso.com/green/renewrpt/20150918_DailyRenewablesWatch.txt http://content.caiso.com/green/renewrpt/20150918_DailyRenewa...
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoVariation and unpredictability are two different things. It varies by geography, but often wind is stronger at night and in the winter but that is different from minute by minute variation, which is what can be reduced by building lots of distributed wind farms. Solar, for example, could be said to have infinite variability since its not available at night, but its actually fairly predicatble if it is spread around geographically.
- hga 11y agoBatteries would help. It will take a lot of them. At least 300,000 Tesla Powerwall battery packs would be required to load balance that variation in wind. That's about a billion dollars, which is not unreasonable. The price would of course go down for quantity, and putting the individual cells into larger units. Let's wave our hands and say 900M -> 500M. But per https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Powerwall https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Powerwall the $3,000 7kWh daily cycle units have a lifetime of "only" 5,000 cycles. So half "a billion dollars" every 13.5 years, ~100K/day.
- ams6110 11y agoIncreased demand for something tends to make it more expensive.
- fulafel 11y agoFor air conditioning (heating or cooling) you don't need to go as high tech as batteries - you can heat/cool water during the night and use it in daytime. This is common in heating applications (due to longstanding night-time electricity discounts) in cooler places of the world. Also works for district cooling.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> Many coal and nuclear plants are actually quite good at load following (at least in France and Germany it's common to run nukes in this mode). The units are quite big so they don't have to do that many % per hour in order to keep up with a wind park. It doesn't really make sense to do this with nuclear. Once you've paid the capital cost to construct a nuclear plant, the fuel cost is completely inconsequential and you might as well run it at 100% constantly. Even if you can vary the load you're better off to find something to use the extra capacity for than, essentially, throwing it away. Of course, that's before politics and market inefficiency. It may be more profitable to reduce supply unnecessarily if it will raise the price per KWh because it's more profitable to generate 900MWh at $.18/KWh than 1000MWh at .04/KWh.
- fulafel 11y agoIn the power system there are plants with different roles. Some of them will be taking care of balancing the power system and others will be mostly running at capacity. Both tasks provide value. You don't need any "unnecessary" reduction in the equation if it's cheaper to slow down some plants than feed the excess power into the market at negative prices.