3 ms·
> I propose that "legal" is the default state for new inventions. This is a pretty ridiculous concept. It would just encourage dodgy entrepeneuers to rapidly
by threeseed 11y ago
> I propose that "legal" is the default state for new inventions.
This is a pretty ridiculous concept.
It would just encourage dodgy entrepeneuers to rapidly produce disruptive products without any care for safety or public benefit. Some things need to be thoroughly tested before releasing them into the public e.g. milk formulas, vaccines, cars otherwise they could kill masses of people before anyone has a chance to stop it.
And in fact a place already exists with lax regulations: China. And look what's happened there over the last few decades. So bad in fact that the public desperately looks to Western countries for food and health products.
- jMyles 11y agoJust so I understand: You are holding up China as a refuge from totalitarian tendencies?
- azernik 11y agoWhen it comes to economic rules, China went from a centrally-controlled economy to a shockingly unregulated (by Western standards) market economy. If you want to speak up against the government you're out of luck, but if you want to sell baby formula without inspections it's much easier than in the States.
- jMyles 11y agoI'm saying: obviously China, which is an environment of dreadful rights of expression of all sorts, is not a good example of the potential of innovation sans government.
- nickv 11y agoYes... China is about as unregulated w.r.t. to industry as you can get. Have you ever seen the air quality in Beijing? Do you remember the air quality in LA in the 80s before stricter CARB standards? (Or are you too young to?)
- jMyles 11y agoI never visted LA in the 80s. I have two friends who live in Shanghai and complain about the air quality. Regardless, the state is no friend to the environment. And as I said to the other commenter, I don't think it's reasonable to hold up China, a huge and corrupt state with no meaningful rights to expression, as an example of innovation sans government.
- bsbechtel 11y agoActually that's pretty much one of the key philosophical tenets of the U.S. Constitution. The idea being that 300 million free individuals can come up with many more good ideas than a few heads of state, and they shouldn't have to wait for some gov regulator to give them the ok to try an idea first.