3 ms·
TI calculators are basically a racket. They are entirely unnecessary (I’d argue distracting and counterproductive) for student learning in the classroom, but vi
by jacobolus 11y ago
TI calculators are basically a racket. They are entirely unnecessary (I’d argue distracting and counterproductive) for student learning in the classroom, but via partnerships with the standardized test and textbook publishers, they’ve convinced American parents, students, and school administrators that they’re essential tools, and can thereby charge $100 for laughably antiquated hardware.
It’s even sillier when you consider most students have a dramatically more capable smartphone in their pockets already. We might as well be teaching students to use Palm Pilots or 15-year-old point-and-shoot digital cameras.
Calling them “pro level” is a joke.. real pros use (e.g.) Matlab, R, Mathematica, or Python.
- wslh 11y agoI remember Steve Wozniak comments about being influenced by a HP calculator, and I ask if we can reinvent the calculator. Probably there is no business here but a short term challenge in UX.
- lfowles 11y agoI think GP might have been getting at TI89 level calculators, which have CAS. That's a significant feature in my book.
- jacobolus 11y agoThe CAS in the TI-89 is a toy compared to Maple, Mathematica, Sage, etc., and typing complicated expressions into a calculator keypad is something mathematical sinners are forced to do eternally in hell.
- bane 11y agoI'm talking even better, but designed with the TI-like way of doing math. Something Matlab/Mathematica-level, but with a more reasonable input interface than something like Python for Android. I had a TI-92+ I used for years instead of fighting with Matlab since I had using it down to muscle memory. It worked well enough (until I needed more pro-level tools). For example, adding better support for matrix math than the TI-89/92 series, and some built in image processing tools...the platform already even has image acquisition hardware. Or a line of USB connectable voltmeters or other data acquisition hardware. For field use, lots of people still use these middle-school calculators because they have a decent combination of power and an interface they've been using for 6-7 years. Heck, I use emulators for TI-83/85/89 on my phone for quick calculations in the field or when I don't want to have to fire up an overpowered tool. The CAS on the 89 is almost magic in lots of cases.
- anon4 11y agoAren't they required for standard tests because you have to calculate a final answer, which is hard by hand, but you can't be allowed to use a full tablet, because it's impossible to secure against cheating?
- hga 11y agoExcept for the minor detail that you can sufficiently test someone's math abilities without the use of a calculator? Or so was the case for me in the '70s when demanding one was out of the question, and e.g. MIT had to figure out if I, and the N thousand other students they offered admission to, could hack the calculus required by the core curriculum (one term beyond the AP Calculus BC sequence (single variable through infinite series)).