4 ms·
> Which is to say that it’s clear whatever condition the strident, proud autistics have, it’s not quite the same condition as one that leaves you epileptic, mut
by PhasmaFelis 11y ago
> Which is to say that it’s clear whatever condition the strident, proud autistics have, it’s not quite the same condition as one that leaves you epileptic, mute, and generally unable to care for yourself.
I can understand the anger here, but please understand that the problem goes both ways. Some high-functioning autistics don't seem to get that the condition can be absolutely crippling, but their belligerence stems from a lifetime of people refusing to admit that they exist or that their experiences have validity. It's frustrating when people who don't know me assume that I need help dressing myself because they knew someone whose kid was severely affected.
- DanBC 11y agoYes. Also many people with ASD recognise that they're on one end of a spectrum, and while they focus on that end they recognise the abuse and maltreatment (from crooks and scammers; from abusive carers; from abusive staff; etc) and they campaign to fix those problems. (At least this is true in the UK.)
- rustynails 11y agoAnother aspect is parents. My wife and I had strong arguments about our child. She refused to accept our child had a problem because she has similar traits. If a parent can't look past their own faults, therapy will not make a difference. It wasn't until a few brave souls approached me that I had a basis to engage my wife that it wasn't me making it up. She misdiagnosed many things on the journey. I feel the need to clarify something. In most ways, my wife is amazing. Very strong willed, clever, independent. She is the only partner I could work with as an equal. As we've worked things through for our child, she's benefitted in many ways too. Not surprisingly, my child's behaviour is like my father in law.
- Mz 11y agoPart of the problem is that autism significantly impacts social function. So does prejudice. So the minute you label someone as autistic, it becomes incredibly difficult to say how much of their daily challenge is due to inability to perform socially and how much is due to other people perceiving them differently and treating them differently. The other thing is that many traits seen in autistic individuals and used to label them as defective are also seen in other situations and not viewed as pathology. One example I know of firsthand: The tendency to be very literal is also seen in highly intelligent and highly educated individuals and is a hallmark of good scientific work. But in a person diagnosed with autism, it is pathologized rather than praised as a virtue. It's a complicated situation. Edit: I apologize. I am leaving the comment here, but I feel like I replied to the wrong person somehow. Perhaps it should have just been a general comment and not a reply to. I have two sons who are not formally diagnosed but likely would qualify for a diagnosis somewhere on the spectrum. I have nothing but sympathy for your frustration.
- Asbostos 11y agoThe author is being a bit prejudiced by saying her severe examples are somehow not acceptable while more high functioning ones are. Most people are unable to care for themselves. We depend on others to help provide food and water for us, accommodation, etc. Most of us won't stay alive if we're isolated from the support of other people we depend on. Some autistic people with more extreme cases not only can't provide their own food, but also can't put on their own clothes. That's just a tighter dependency but not distinctly bad. I've heard similar arguments about Downs syndrome. Some people want to prevent it, but others say let's embrace it and recognize that the patients are still people who still get to experience life just like the rest of us. They might not be capable of some things we are, but hey, we're not capable of some things a superhuman AGI robot would be either. We wouldn't want to sterilize all humans just because intelligent robots appear and we feel our life has become relatively worthless.
- CydeWeys 11y ago> Most people are unable to care for themselves. We depend on others to help provide food and water for us, accommodation, etc. Most of us won't stay alive if we're isolated from the support of other people we depend on. Some autistic people with more extreme cases not only can't provide their own food, but also can't put on their own clothes. Did you mean to say "Most [autistic] people" in the first line? Because if you didn't, then your comment seems like a non sequitur to me. Of course most people can take care of themselves. If they didn't, then society would collapse, as there would be more people requiring care than those able to give care. This discussion isn't about the interconnectedness of the modern world. Yes, we no longer live in a hunter-gather society, and most people probably couldn't farm their own crops or hunt their own game, but that's not what we mean when we're talking about people who are unable to care for themselves. What we mean is someone who is unable to earn money, who cannot navigate purchasing food at grocery stores, who cannot arrange their own accommodation. I live in Manhattan -- because there is no game to hunt here and no available land to farm, would you truly paint me as someone "unable to care for themselves" simply because I have to subsist on food from grocery stores and restaurants that is trucked in from farms in areas with less expensive real estate? Similarly for water that comes from the municipal water supply?