3 ms·
Some caveats: -Many people do not tolerate high fat diets well. For them such diets are not an option. -A low carb high fat diet is pretty suboptimal for ath
by wdewind 11y ago
Some caveats:
-Many people do not tolerate high fat diets well. For them such diets are not an option.
-A low carb high fat diet is pretty suboptimal for athletes. Many proponents of low carb diets attempt to mitigate this by having athletes eat carbs only around training sessions. The problem with this is it greatly ignores the science showing carbohydrates' usefulness in the recovery process, specifically in building and maintaining muscle mass. It's important to move out of a mindset of "good vs bad" food and into one of goal oriented eating. If you are an athlete and you are eating very low carbs, you should probably reevaluate. If you are not an athlete and are eating significant amounts of carbs, you should probably reevaluate. Putting jet fuel into a car is not a good idea, but the inverse is true as well.
-There is not science showing high fat diets perform any differently than high carb diets when calories are equalized for the purpose of weight loss. High fat is a compliance hack, allowing some people to more comfortably consume fewer calories than they do on a high carb diet. Many people talk about insulin spikes etc., when talking about high carb. That's kind a red herring: insulin spikes happen with significant amounts of protein as well, and they really aren't a bad thing.
-Cutting out carbs usually leads to an initial 5lbs-ish drop in water weight, which makes people look less bloated pretty quickly, provided they were coming from a poor diet in the first place.
- beachstartup 11y ago> Many people talk about insulin spikes etc., when talking about high carb. That's kind a red herring: insulin spikes happen with significant amounts of protein as well, and they really aren't a bad thing. high fat != high protein fat is not the same as protein. you can eat fat without eating protein. it may sound obvious, but i don't know how you read an entire article about fat, write 3 paragraphs about fat, and then conclude with a fact about protein. wtf???
- wdewind 11y agoYou're right but the point about protein wasn't specifically about protein, it was about insulin and how focusing on insulin levels (with the exception of diabetics) is not really a useful thing to do when talking about weight loss and nutritional health. If your pancreas is functioning properly then insulin spikes are not something you need to be worrying about, and often they are used as the reason that high fat diets are better. My main point is that carbs and fat behave very similarly as energy sources, and that to focus on removing carbs because you can blunt your insulin spikes is idiotic. If removing carbs helps you cut calories consistently by all means go ahead. But if you think it's some magic bullet you're misreading the science.