2 ms·
Thanks for the very detailed response - very informative. The core of my argument is that we really need more of this: > Now there are other attempts to explai
by zamalek 11y ago
Thanks for the very detailed response - very informative. The core of my argument is that we really need more of this:
> Now there are other attempts to explain some of these effects e.g. the gravitational waves from super massive black holes [...]
We just need to be looking at other options. It seems as though we are spending a lot of thinking time on one solution and it's frustration with that which likely leads me to words such as "hacks."
> Mercury
I wasn't suggesting it was the same thing, merely making an analogy: a somewhat similar type of mistake we made in the past. WIMPs could be real but they could just be the modern day Vulcan: I watched a great talk by Prof. Terry Rudolph[1] and he points out that our monkey brains have problems visualizing things smaller than "banana." Possibly our brains have problem visualizing forces bigger than "moon" and therefore we create these physical phenomena (Vulcan/WIMP) in a desperate attempt to conceptualize them.
While WIMPs may very well be the correct solution, I'd just like to see a little more energy spent exploring other solutions. Science is very much about being correct nowadays: getting published, getting the Nobel Prize, etc. I think it's far more rewarding to be wrong and science needs to briefly contemplate the philosophical roots that it was born of.
[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JKGZDhQoR9E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JKGZDhQoR9E
- dogma1138 11y agoI agree that biological limitations could enforce very real limits on what we can come up with, I have real doubts that we could understand or formulate (working) physics that cover multiple dimensions for that same reason. But we are looking, both dark matter and dark energy have multiple candidates. Maybe Einstein was correct and we have a (small but positive) universal constant AKA space-time's property tax. Other various proposed fields like the quintessence theory, and some various views on QFT could also be an answer to that. So you have allot of different theories and proposal from small hacks like the universal constant to completely new theories but they pretty much are aimed and answering the same thing and are labeled under "dark energy". Dark matter is the same thing, most candidates for dark matter are quite different and they all attempt to explain why we are all fatter than we think we are through different mechanisms. We also have some other efforts to create completely different explanations for gravity like MOND that was mentioned. So I don't really see that we are limiting ourselves, but as I said before you have to start searching for something at a known point or go completely out of left field, and so far usually you need a little (or well allot) of both because rarely (at least these days) were we can be off by so much that we need to rewrite the text books.
- zamalek 11y agoIt seems as though we are partially in agreement. Thanks for the great discussion!