8 ms·
The Tragedy of One Laptop Per Child
- GiraffeNecktie 17y agoHuh? In what way is this a "tragedy"? Lack of clean water and mosquito nets is a tragedy. The 2004 tsunami was a tragedy. I don't know if the OLPC is a worthy goal or not but I'm quite sure it's not a tragedy that children don't have access to computers and it's not a tragedy that someone is trying to make them available.
- JabavuAdams 17y agoIn terms of mis-spent resources: i.e. opportunity costs. If the OLPC project is in fact a failure, consider how many mosquito nets could have been bought with the funds.* * Yes, I know people / companies would not have donated the same amount of $ for a non-sexy cause.
- notauser 17y agoIt seems more efficient to try and raise economic activity to the point where foreign aid is no longer required; the OLPC was an attempt to do this through jump starting technology education. The areas for which it was intended did not need mosquito nets - places such as rural Mexico. These places have power and running water. While saving lives is a worthwhile goal, saving them just so they can carry on being perpetually dependent on foreign aid seems to be pretty unfair on both the nations giving aid and the nations receiving it.
- GiraffeNecktie 17y agoA failure is hardly the same thing as a tragedy. The words are not interchangeable. People working toward the same end using different methods is not a tragedy even if one method is "better" than another.
- jasonlbaptiste 17y agoLack of knowledge and opportunity is certainly a tragedy. Buying all the mosquito nets to save lives is pretty useless if we don't help those same people grasp opportunity and become educated. The two causes are exclusive in terms of donation. Just because I donate to prevent Malaria does not mean I can't spend just as much or more to OLPC.
- notauser 17y agoTo illustrate the scale of the tragedy there are around 1.1bn people living in poverty. If those people had been afforded opportunities similar to those available in the US their total salaries would be somewhere between $20 and $40 trillion. That's a huge amount of wasted potential - all those resources could be working on making all of our lives better - advancing medicine, computer science, engineering and other things. Instead they are living miserable lives in atrocious slums.
- tokenadult 17y agoIf those people had been afforded opportunities similar to those available in the US their total salaries would be somewhere between $20 and $40 trillion. Perhaps, but affording those people opportunities similar to those available in the United States might cost a great deal of money, and might also involve controversial steps such as overthrowing corrupt governments and promoting English rather than local languages as a language of school instruction. Poor countries (I have lived in them) are interacting systems of climate, natural resource base, cultural tradition, existing economic level, existing level of education, international trade patterns, political system, and other influences, and thus poor countries don't change overnight.
- notauser 17y agoIndeed, which is why a small step (such as introducing a large number of cheap computers) is the only practical step. You can't wait for perfection - you have to get started with what's practical now and iterate. Equal opportunity for all is the long term goal, not something you should expect tomorrow. Fortunately whatever else the OLPC project did, it inspired the Eee and that inspired a whole generation of low power, cheap devices which are (more) affordable for everyone. That may not be the step they expected, but it's one in the right direction!
- tokenadult 17y agoI'm quite sure it's not a tragedy that children don't have access to computers This is an example of a radical opinion that one might expect to be downvoted for disagreement here on HN, but I see (from current net upvotes) that others agree, or at least think the comment contributes to the discussion here. I'll expand on this a bit, from my perspective as a parent of wealthy-country children who have long had access to computers. Of course I grew up without ready computer access. Children having personal computers with online access is, like most of human life, a TRADE-OFF. I think computers are wonderful tools and helpful for self-directed learning, but they are also enormous time sinks and distractions from books and many hands-on activities. Current research doesn't unambiguously show that computer use contrasted with nonuse is even an advantage for learning K-12 academic subjects. (Some studies appear to show academic achievement going down as computer use goes up in developed countries.) The role of easy telecommunications in fostering economic development seems beyond dispute, but voice telephony and an efficient postal system for adults may go most of the way to providing that benefit, without all children needing an Internet-connected laptop. I have lived in poor countries, which is why I am conscious that where money is scarce, one must think about what way of spending money produces the best results. The OLPC project certainly had noble goals, and strove to be inexpensive, but perhaps the countries the project intended to serve need something else more urgently.
- martincmartin 17y agoI think the biggest contribution of OLPC was to scare both hardware makers and Microsoft into creating netbooks. We wouldn't have netbooks today without OLPC. No one wanted to sell low end laptops because they wanted to maintain profit margins. Perhaps OLPC will goad others into making great tablet PCs as well.
- cema 17y agoAn interesting take. I do not remember it this way, however. Any links, papers, etc, with supporting evidence?
- nostrademons 17y agoI remember it that way. When the OLPC was first announced in 2005, a "cheap" laptop was $799-999, and a decent one was about $1600. Now an average laptop (as long as it's not a Mac) is around $500, with cheap netbooks in the $300 range. Citations: http://blogs.computerworld.com/what_was_the_first_netbook http://blogs.computerworld.com/what_was_the_first_netbook http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Netbook http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Netbook
- fnid 17y agoYou're absolutely right, that's exactly how I remember it too. People used to call me all the time, "I can't find a laptop under $1,000, help! What should I buy? Should I just get a desktop for $700? I can use the same monitor." Now, my next portable is going to cost $100. It might be a tablet. Not too long from now, they're going to be in refrigerator magnets for $5.
- NathanKP 17y agoIf you are trying to say that the OLPC was what drove down laptop prices I would have to disagree. The OLPC was made possible by the same forces that drove down other laptop prices: cheaper electronics parts. OLPC may have had a slight effect, but the larger cause was the natural development of computing technology. As electronics advance prices drop at a fairly predictable rate. What cost $100 this year is probably going to cost $50 next year, and $25 the year after that. That is the real reason why laptops have gotten so cheap, not because of anything the OLPC foundation has done.
- patrickgzill 17y agoThere is good that will come from OLPC even if OLPC as an organization were to vanish tomorrow. PixelQi.com (spinoff from former CTO of OLPC) has developed a high-resolution LCD technology that will compete with e-Ink; since it uses mainstream LCD manufacturing the economies of scale will mean it will be much cheaper to produce an 11" e-reader. Assuming PixelQI succeeds, this means even more e-readers for less money, and and an increase in whatever you perceive the benefits of e-readers to be (such as less paper waste, or better use of time). The Sugar project http://www.sugarlabs.org/ http://www.sugarlabs.org/ is the software side of OLPC, able to be run from USB sticks on any old PC you have lying around; a P3-700 or higher is still pretty snappy. I know of several test implementations using it, for real, in schools (there are still bugs to work out until it can be deployed widely).
- nicpottier 17y agoI think it is a bit premature to call it a failure. I think there is far too much focus on the hardware going on. The fact is that OLPC is actually doing some pretty good work. Yes, the hardware is more expensive than they had hoped, but it is still really cheap, and the simplified UI does seem to work pretty well. Their latest deployment is in Rwanda, and although I will fully admit that I was chagrined to see OLPC still selling, once I watched some of the videos and did some reading it was clear that they are actually doing some real good. See: http://www.informationweek.com/video/infrastructure/3655781001;jsessionid=EZDAWPSXTDX1VQE1GHPSKH4ATMY32JVN http://www.informationweek.com/video/infrastructure/36557810... There is something to be said for having a bright green laptop that isn't terribly useful for adults and doesn't run a standard OS. It makes them less of a target for theft or resale in poorer countries and keeps them in the hands of the people that need them, the students. I think a lot of good is yet to come from OLPC, it is just taking a lot longer than they expected. I do however fully agree that the touchscreen vision is a joke.
- ja27 17y agoNeat hardware progress aside, has OLPC been a success in actually educating the target kids? Just putting laptops in hands doesn't automatically educate them. Here in the U.S., there are plenty of schools with computer labs, computers in classrooms, or even, yes, one laptop per child. Based all my teacher and parent friends, all the increased access to computers here hasn't really improved education much. And we're buying expensive commercial educational software, not just Sugar or gCompris. Maybe the time and money is better spent funding CC / public domain textbooks? That and Sugar are what I'm more interested in supporting.
- qjz 17y agoTo paraphrase you, just putting books in hands doesn't automatically educate them, either. There have been, and always will be, challenges in education. But for those who are willing and able to make good use of the resources available to them, computers and the Internet are two very powerful resources.
- rbanffy 17y agoI really hate to see people bashing the OLPC for the wrong reasons. The project has a lot of flaws and a good couple lose ends, but, all in all, it is a great idea that has faced huge resistance from the very governments that should embrace it. I also suspect some governments active sabotage it because such a device allowing communication and free access to information would weaken their grip on local populations. You really don't need the courseware, at least not at the start. All you really need to start is the regular textbooks transcribed as e-books. The kid can then carry and access all their books, current and future, in one compact volume, breaking any limitation on the kid's reading. Since OLPSs have network connections, governments (and educational associations) can also spend some money translating relevant topics from wikipedia, creating better localized versions. Classroom activities can also be developed on top of the localized software that already ships with them. It's also lovely to suppose that local people cannot fix the machine because "this intended market is illiterate". Living in a third world country, I am deeply offended. This is, however, a failure of the OLPC plan. The OLPC should also have been directed towards US schools in order to gain momentum, perhaps even before attempting to go after the third world. It's also foolish to overpromise impossible hardware. XO-2 and XO-3 are ludicrous. XO-1.75 is great, however. I love the idea of Windows-proofing it by running on ARM. I fail to see the educational value of running MS Ofice. But it's absolutely unfair to expect the OLPC folks to develop courseware for the machine beyond the outstanding materials already there.
- mattm 17y agoFunny how people with the biggest dreams end up taking the most flack. OLPC was a big ambition and, like most new initiatives, was probably bound to fail initially. However, he had an idea and he did it! The great success is that future initiatives will have the opportunity to learn and improve upon it. Are there other things that need fixing around the world? Yes, but the argument that we cannot do anything grand until every single primitive human need is solved is bunk. Innovation does not need to wait for a utopia.
- teeja 17y ago"What’s the courseware and curriculum?" And if you don't ask this question first, your well-intended project to 'gift the poor' becomes 'abetting the criminals'. Examples: FM. Television. Someone will fill the vacuum. I maintain that there's a huge, untapped market for ed. software. Wikipedia is a powerful clue ... and, now, a free resource. But education's a lot more than shoveling data.