3 ms·
I agree you don't see it, but I don't think that merits your insulting assumptions and language about me and what I know. To see this guy as acting parasitical
by wpietri 11y ago
I agree you don't see it, but I don't think that merits your insulting assumptions and language about me and what I know.
To see this guy as acting parasitically, all you need do is take him at his word. He has a calculated economic value for the miles that is far larger than what he paid for them. He himself believes that Avis values them and would see him as a scammer, which is why he carefully limited the size of his grift and energetically persuaded employees to do things that they realized made no sense. I don't see anything wrong with assuming that he's right.
To double-check, though, there are plenty of reasonable estimates on what air miles actually cost out on the web, and the guy's estimate of the economic value is in line with those. And Avis's promotion looks like a pretty typical customer acquisition thing where you pay some sort of initial acquisition cost and hope to make your money back over time. They did not acquire 37 customers here, or even 1, so the guy is entirely reasonable in thinking that Avis would stop him if he did this at scale.
So the balance of the evidence is that 37rentals is, as he himself thinks, scamming Avis out of a lot of miles. Is this CERN-level proof? No, but I don't think it's necessary here. We're on a forum, discussing another forum post. My assumptions are reasonable and are based on my many years in business. If you have evidence for other assumptions you'd like to make, godspeed. But for a guy wrongly in a lather about supposed no-evidence assertions, you are making a lot of no-evidence assertions yourself. Anonymously, of course.
- dlss 11y agoWhen I saw you'd replied here, I excitedly checked https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10218108 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10218108 to see if you'd also given saurik a reply. Alas, no. You choose to reply here stating you believe OP agrees with your assumptions, while ignoring more detailed replies to your position. For my part, I think that if OP agreed with you he wouldn't have done it. This whole thing reminds me of a discussion I once had about doctors who perform abortions... Some people find it very hard to understand the other side doesn't agree that life begins at conception, and wrongly conclude abortion doctors must believe they're committing murder. It's always easier to brush other positions off as too verbose, or too anonymous, or too whatever. It's much harder (but much more valuable) to consider the problem and data at length, and come to a new truth. This is what differentiates science from the tinkering which proceeded it. > Is this CERN-level proof? No, but I don't think it's necessary here. We're on a forum, discussing another forum post. This is what I was talking about when I said "it matters to me that HackerNews remain a place for intelligent discussion" above -- to me HN isn't just some online forum; the standards we should hold ourselves to are much higher. We're here to learn and relate. If you'd acted this way on reddit I wouldn't have taken issue... but on HN it pains me to see this kind of behavior. The other side of your holy war is not inherently immoral.