2 ms·
"modification" applies specifically to the code as is installed and shipped. Picture the scenario at the manufacturer where one developer is being tasked with
by mindslight 11y ago
"modification" applies specifically to the code as is installed and shipped.
Picture the scenario at the manufacturer where one developer is being tasked with creating a new feature using a consumer unit fresh off the line, for a business demo. What resources do they utilize in the course of doing this? This is the company's "preferred form" of the source tree for modifying an as-shipped device, and is what needs to be made public.
The company could supply a firmware update to overwrite the bootloader and stub out signature checking, if that is what makes sense. Or a well-specified description to use JTAG to do the same. Or perhaps they don't actually care about security and 'make dist' creates an installable image.
The thing is, all of these arguments ("preferred form for modification", the key being part of the installation script, code+signature being the executable work) seem like uphill battles when trying to show the manufacturer is violating them in an informal forum like HN.
But the intent and spirit of the license is straightforward and even spelled out in the preamble! "Our General Public Licenses are designed to make sure ... you can change the software". Fulling these goals is the entire point of the contract and only consideration for receiving a license. So the manufacturer is actually the party that must work to show how what they're releasing actually fulfills the specific terms.