3 ms·
Did you actually read right to the end? "But in fact, at the time this game was played there was no specific rule stating that a pawn had to be promote
by ColinWright 11y ago
Did you actually read right to the end?
"But in fact, at the time this game was played
there was no specific rule stating that a pawn
had to be promoted to a piece of the same colour!
- ubernostrum 11y agoOf course there was also no rule saying that chess functioned on a restrictive rules system and a lot of evidence that it instead functioned on a permissive system. Which would invalidate the "no rule says I can't" argument. (when designing a game's rules, "restrictive" means the approach is "everything is permitted by default, unless explicitly restricted", while "permissive" means "everything is forbidden by default unless explicitly permitted" -- if we assume that chess is a restrictive-rules game, we can similarly mate in one from almost any position by simply inventing new pieces with unusual abilities and declaring that "the rules don't say you can't!")
- mikeash 11y agoIf the rule was simply, "A promoted pawn may be exchanged for any piece," then that would fit within a permissive system, and still qualify as "nothing says you have to promote to the same color."
- Maken 11y agoSo, promoting a pawn in chess is undefined behavior?
- dragonwriter 11y agoNo, its defined (both then and now), its just the spec has had breaking changes from earlier versions.
- lmm 11y agoNo. It was unclear whether you could promote to a piece of the other colour, but a conforming implementation of chess will not make demons fly out of your nose.