3 ms·
Okay, I'm interested in some more detail regarding your concerns. In particular, why do you consider their track record to be horrible, and what actions should
by ghshephard 17y ago
Okay, I'm interested in some more detail regarding your concerns. In particular, why do you consider their track record to be horrible, and what actions should they have been taking to prevent liquid detonated PETN bombs?
Off the top of my head, I can fault the TSA for only two things:
1. They don't have Full Body Scanners in place. The technology has been around for 3+ years, and would have caught the PETN sewn into the underwear.
2. They still allow liquids onto planes, which can be used to detonate and/or do significant damage to the inside of an airplane.
You clearly have your own list of steps the TSA could have taken - I'm wondering what they are?
- lhuang 17y ago1. There have been numerous "breaches" conducted by journalists, etc. over the years. 2. I think the greater point isn't that the TSA is ineffective but rather that they are inefficient. Making millions of travelers each year jump through more and more hoops isn't making any of us safer. A smart, determined, terrorist will easily smuggle something aboard. I've personally walked through security a half dozen times with a lighter in my bag (forgot it was even there) when flying both domestic and international, including going from AMS to IAD. Plus how many TSA screeners have you seen just aimlessly do their job? You think these guys have real incentive to catch smart/determined terrorists? The fact is the TSA has burned through billions of dollars (your money) that may have been better spent on intelligence and more robust "threat list" monitoring systems. Not to mention on a bevy of other issues they could have tackled with that money. The TSA going after a few bloggers is inane. Do you feel safer knowing that a bunch of knucklehead TSA agents wasted tax payer money to intimidate a bunch of bloggers? Will the confidentiality of a stupid list of hoops travelers must jump through make you safer? Is the end-result even a net positive for society? Is it even CLOSE?
- ahlatimer 17y agoI forgot that I had a multitool attached to my keys when I went through security about a year ago. I actually took my keys out, put them in the basket, and walked through. No agent said anything until the return trip, where I was asked to either check my bag or throw it away.
- kelnos 17y agoI used to have a mini-Leatherman attached to my key ring, which had a small knife on it. I'd often forget to take it off when traveling, and it made it through airport security on at least 4 trips (so at least 8 times through the x-ray machine), probably more. Ironically, it wasn't the TSA who eventually took it from me, but security outside a club in San Francisco.
- philk 17y ago1) A more exhaustive list of faults can be found at wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transportation_Security_Administration#Criticisms_and_scandals http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transportation_Security_Adminis...) 2) The liquids threat has been overblown; there are doubts that they pose a significant threat and in the 2006 transatlantic aircraft plot (which was going to be supposedly carried out with liquids) the plotters were arrested on the ground days before any attack was to occur. To reiterate, they were arrested by old fashioned police work, not airport screening procedures. >> You clearly have your own list of steps the TSA could have taken - I'm wondering what they are? The best thing to do would be to scale back the focus on the TSA and spend the money on better policing and intelligence work.
- rdtsc 17y agoWell as I said their track record is very bad. They have not stopped red-handed a single terrorist or a single real bomb. It is usually an air marshal, other intelligence or just near-by passengers that did the work for them. Yet they have sucked billions of dollars of our money. If we "the people" are the employers and TSA is working for us to keep us safe, it would be reasonable for us to fire them immediatly. As for your concerns: > 1. They don't have Full Body Scanners in place. The technology has been around for 3+ years, and would have caught the PETN sewn into the underwear. There are also body cavities. Would you suggest probing everyone's cavities then? > 2. They still allow liquids onto planes, which can be used to detonate and/or do significant damage to the inside of an airplane. Refer to my answer to point 1. Body cavities can hide liquids, powder gels, anything non-metalic. Even with their existing control they have let liquids and weapons through on numerous time. So my list of steps that TSA could have taken is: 1. Quit