5 ms·
Am I missing something, or does "turning off" a thermostat not really make that much sense? And therefore, a UI that made that easy and obvious, wouldn't really
by ZeroGravitas 11y ago
Am I missing something, or does "turning off" a thermostat not really make that much sense? And therefore, a UI that made that easy and obvious, wouldn't really be that good a UI?
- dack 11y agoWhen a thermostat is on, it controls the temperature. If you don't want to control the temperature, would you not want to turn the thermostat off?
- eterm 11y agoThe post said he/she wanted to turn it off because they were too cold, which seems a strange response. Surely what they wanted was to adjust the thermostat temperature?
- throwaway049 11y agoI think it was meant as 'turn off the AC' which would allow the room temp to equalize with the outside world. I'm used to stand alone AC units so I think in terms of 'turn it off to allow room temp to rise'.
- Karunamon 11y agoKind of like a light switch. The device is carrying out its function even when switched off.
- vonmoltke 11y agoI turn off my HVAC frequently in the transition months between winter and summer. I would not buy a thermostat that did not allow me to do that, and this "feature" is yet another knock against Nest that will keep me from buying one.
- rblatz 11y agoThere are two easy ways to turn the nest off. Press the dial in and turn it off. Or from anywhere in the world from your phone. Also you can set it to heat/cool and set ranges where it will cool above x temperature and heat below y temperature.
- bduerst 11y agoI don't use a Nest thermostat but isn't that exactly something that Nest does? Program and schedule dates that you want your HVAC off?
- smackfu 11y agoFor reference, the very common Honeywell thermostats that seem to be in every US house built in the last 20 minutes just have an unmarked button that cycles between Auto, Off, Heat, and Cool. (Auto means Heat/Cool.) It does have the advantage that there are only four buttons on the whole unit, so trial and error works pretty well.
- treerock 11y agoYeah, that was my first thought. I'm thinking there are two things at play. I'm from Scotland where nobody has AC, so when you are cold, you turn on the 'heating'. And generally we have a separate control panel and thermostat so they don't get merged in my head and I would never say 'switch off the thermostat' when I meant 'switch off the heating/AC'. https://xkcd.com/1576/ https://xkcd.com/1576/