4 ms·
What is the most worrying aspect of proven-unhackable kernels is that eventually these projects will be used to prevent people from modifying their system. Pro
by mschuster91 11y ago
What is the most worrying aspect of proven-unhackable kernels is that eventually these projects will be used to prevent people from modifying their system.
Proven unjailbreakable phones are the wet dream of the mobile carrier industry - finally no piracy anymore and no way for users to get rid of bloatware.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoSadly, you're correct. The protections that were on the Xbox 360 and in Apple phones started out as academic explorations in secure hardware. Many of these have direct application to DRM. Microsoft is heavily invested in them. It can still be done with user in control but device and OS manufacturers have opposite incentives.
- wingless 11y ago...until someone develops a hardware exploit and starts selling kits. Which is already happening for many devices, by the way.
- userbinator 11y agoThat raises the barrier substantially, however. Also, you can bet that the hardware will be secured too - just look at the technology available currently for things like credit cards and payment systems (where I think the security is somewhat more justified.)
- mtgx 11y agoThat may come soon anyway with Intel Skylake's SGX.
- gue5t 11y agoMaybe then we'll be able to convince people that they can't use benevolent hackers (geohotz, comex, et al.) as the get-out-of-jail-free card for having given money to companies that do not respect them. The current status quo of the open-source community being able to make use of closed-source hardware, often producing viable devices where the vendors had hoped to provide something locked-down and near useless (e.g. openwrting routers, or that amazon button thing) is very nice, but does substantially draw wind out of the sails of open hardware initiatives: with companies able to subsidize the cost of hardware using other revenue streams, groups aiming to produce open-source hardware have to deal with not only per-unit costs being much higher due to smaller production runs but also the ability of many companies to sell hardware below reasonable prices due to charging for associated proprietary services. If open hardware becomes the only hardware on which open software can run, its value proposition changes significantly for the better.