7 ms·
I'm wondering if there are any of us who would suggest that right after a terrorist attack, it might be a good idea _not_ to share with the bad guys how we're g
by ghshephard 17y ago
I'm wondering if there are any of us who would suggest that right after a terrorist attack, it might be a good idea _not_ to share with the bad guys how we're going to stop them? I mean, maybe hold off for a week or so while we figure out if:
A) There are more attacks coming.
B) How we are going to stop them.
- rdtsc 17y agoYou are assuming that what TSA was doing, is doing and is planning to do stopped/is stopping/will stop terrorist attacks. Their track record is so horrible that they should be fired on the spot, be asked to apologize to everyone they harassed over the years and be forced to return tax payer's money they wasted for expensive x-ray vision and air puffing machines. To bring back an analogy I made in a previous post, they are like the witch doctor that is trying to cure cancer with a rattle or a voodoo doll. The patients keep dying so as far as they can see, the rattle is not advanced enough. Now they've enhanced the rattle with more bells and added more rules that patients have to follow to get cured. Of course, those who see through the farce and write about it, get some personal attention and home visits...
- robotrout 17y agoWow, that's a lot of vitriol and indignation, considering their record is actually perfect. Did they get lucky a few times to keep that perfect record? Sure they did. But you can't know what would have happened if they hadn't been there. The air puffing machines were a pretty ambitious project, carried out in the haste that comes from knowing that every day you delay may be the day that a preventable tragedy occurs. It's easy to make bad decisions in such a situation. To be able to do chemical analysis, in the field, sampling completely uncontrolled inputs, all completely automated with no chemical analysis expert on-hand to vet the results, and the expectation of no false positives to inconvenience anybody. Seems like you could cut them a little slack. As for the "x-ray vision", as you call it. That seems to work great. It's hampered by public body modesty taboos because it works too well. Anyway, I'm surprised at your level of angst over this.
- philk 17y agoGiven TSA screeners have failed to detect most fake bombs I think you can put their success rate down to terrorism being incredibly rare rather than competence on their part: "Screeners at Los Angeles International Airport missed about 75% of simulated explosives and bomb parts that Transportation Security Administration testers hid under their clothes or in carry-on bags at checkpoints, the TSA report shows." (source:http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2007-10-17-airport-security_N.htm http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2007-10-17-airport-secur...)
- robotrout 17y agoThat's why the air puffer would have been really cool, had it worked. Again, we're to the body modesty. Short of clothing penetrating scanners, either visual or chemical, you're left with somebody caressing you thoroughly to detect these bombs. Caressing you very, very thoroughly. This last guy's underwear bomb was actually molded into the shape of his butt, as near as I could tell from the photo they showed. At this point, the public isn't willing to allow that sort of intimacy between them and their security personnel, and, frankly, the TSA operators are probably also not willing to do it. At some point, as it usually does, I suspect technology will solve this.
- jacquesm 17y agoIf you think technology will solve terrorism I think you're entirely on the wrong path. As security in the computer world shows it takes only a relatively small number of miscreants before you have the ability to hinder the lives of a very large number of people. You need a near 100% success rate in order to control the problem through technology, something you are unlikely to achieve. A real solution, therefore, must be sought outside the technological arena and at a much earlier stage in the lives of the would-be-terrorists than several hours before they are about to detonate a bomb. Countering radicalization is probably a much better way to spend all that money than by spending it on technology.
- ghshephard 17y agoOkay, I'm interested in some more detail regarding your concerns. In particular, why do you consider their track record to be horrible, and what actions should they have been taking to prevent liquid detonated PETN bombs? Off the top of my head, I can fault the TSA for only two things: 1. They don't have Full Body Scanners in place. The technology has been around for 3+ years, and would have caught the PETN sewn into the underwear. 2. They still allow liquids onto planes, which can be used to detonate and/or do significant damage to the inside of an airplane. You clearly have your own list of steps the TSA could have taken - I'm wondering what they are?
- lhuang 17y ago1. There have been numerous "breaches" conducted by journalists, etc. over the years. 2. I think the greater point isn't that the TSA is ineffective but rather that they are inefficient. Making millions of travelers each year jump through more and more hoops isn't making any of us safer. A smart, determined, terrorist will easily smuggle something aboard. I've personally walked through security a half dozen times with a lighter in my bag (forgot it was even there) when flying both domestic and international, including going from AMS to IAD. Plus how many TSA screeners have you seen just aimlessly do their job? You think these guys have real incentive to catch smart/determined terrorists? The fact is the TSA has burned through billions of dollars (your money) that may have been better spent on intelligence and more robust "threat list" monitoring systems. Not to mention on a bevy of other issues they could have tackled with that money. The TSA going after a few bloggers is inane. Do you feel safer knowing that a bunch of knucklehead TSA agents wasted tax payer money to intimidate a bunch of bloggers? Will the confidentiality of a stupid list of hoops travelers must jump through make you safer? Is the end-result even a net positive for society? Is it even CLOSE?
- ahlatimer 17y agoI forgot that I had a multitool attached to my keys when I went through security about a year ago. I actually took my keys out, put them in the basket, and walked through. No agent said anything until the return trip, where I was asked to either check my bag or throw it away.
- jfager 17y agoIt was a document sent to thousands of people at airports and airlines internationally, it wasn't classified, and it describes what millions of passengers are going to experience firsthand going through security lines. In other words: not exactly a secret, and certainly not worth going brownshirt on bloggers for.
- philk 17y agoNo. 1) The TSA is a farce. They've done more damage to the US economy than the terrorists themselves. 2) The changes themselves aren't intended to stop terrorism. They're intended to satisfy the public that "something is being done". 3) Terrorism is extremely rare anyway. If people spent more time worrying about not smoking (for example) and less time worrying about terrorists we'd save thousands of lives every year. The best thing we could do to fight the bad guys is ignore them and get on with our lives.