3 ms·
Visa and co. are big—really big—so I've never understood why they've not just leaned on the OS manufacturers and browser makers to provide them some form of uni
by derefr 11y ago
Visa and co. are big—really big—so I've never understood why they've not just leaned on the OS manufacturers and browser makers to provide them some form of unique, unforgeable signal to users that they're interacting with a real bank.
There could be, say, an HTML5-exposed API capable of triggering "super-modal" forms (like OS UAC does) if-and-only-if the page is being served from a secure origin cross-signed by some "Web Banking Working Group Certificate Authority" that all the banks and OS makers are members of.
- danneu 11y agoWell, the more you rely on a strong signal like that, the easier it is to get phished by sufficient approximations.
- MichaelGG 11y agoEh they don't even bother with a real-looking domain name or a non-phishy form. Seems like they are too out of touch or simply not paying attention.
- acdha 11y agoThe better way to do this would be some sort of two-factor thing – e.g. imagine if the physical card had the equivalent of an embedded RSA-style one-time code generator or, better, a U2F USB/NFC device – which would be resistant to UI spoofing or, in the U2F case, phishing. Unfortunately the banks have less motivation to invest in this as long as the costs of fraud are pushed onto merchants and all of the major players charge similar fees. If something like Apple Pay starts to catch on, perhaps we'll see that change once the banks’ main concern is avoiding a single vendor getting too much market share.
- Symbiote 11y agoSomething similar was used in the UK for online banking, using a small reader [1]. It's a feature of EMV (chip) cards. [1] https://c2.staticflickr.com/2/1218/1438197131_1e0d474266_b.jpg https://c2.staticflickr.com/2/1218/1438197131_1e0d474266_b.j...
- kalleboo 11y agoOne of my Swedish banks uses a chip-and-pin reader for 3DSecure. You insert your card, authenticate with your PIN, and then sign a nonce to validate your transaction. https://farm4.staticflickr.com/3237/2486214902_8feafd8200_b.jpg https://farm4.staticflickr.com/3237/2486214902_8feafd8200_b.... Another one uses a smartphone 2FA app.
- plumeria 11y agoHow about OTP-enabled credit cards? [1] For every transaction the customer must enter the OTP. It wouldn't serve much for subscriptions, though. [1] http://web.deepnetsecurity.com/products2/PocketID.asp http://web.deepnetsecurity.com/products2/PocketID.asp