5 ms·
The Private Islands Inside National Parks
- jonah 11y agoThey're pretty interesting. The inholdings I've encountered are in the Los Padres National Forest in central California. It's strange to be hiking miles and miles into the wilderness and then come across a homestead complete with a house, barns, fences, horses, mules, and orchards. This one and others I've seen in the area have been privately owned for many, many years.
- chrissnell 11y agoNational Forests are another story altogether. There are many, many parcels of private land inside them. Some NFs are more private than they are public. Here's a longtime favorite spot of mine, in the middle of a National Monument. I was driving offroad through this area and stumbled upon this massive, 200+ acre field that had been cleared of cedar. There was a for-sale sign and they wanted around $2,500,000 for this plot. My dream homesite if I had the cash: https://goo.gl/maps/5iKAg https://goo.gl/maps/5iKAg
- jonah 11y agoThat's pretty neat, though I'd probably prefer trees on a good part of mine.
- ClintEhrlich 11y agoI'm surprised (but pleased) that the federal government hasn't simply used eminent domain to seize all of the private land within national parks. The idealistic side of me wants to believe that it's because these people aren't interfering with the purpose of the park(s), and so there is no reason to force them out. But the cynical side of me says that it's more likely that the individuals who own this land are so rich that taking action against them would be impracticable politically.
- kijin 11y agoNot everyone owns a luxury resort. Most of the landowners probably aren't that rich. They just happened to own some rural land when the surrounding area was declared a national park, and most rural land isn't particularly valuable. As for the government, why waste time and money on a politically unpopular move (eminent domain) when they have no immediate use for that land? Since most rural land is cheap, buying might be cheaper than the cost of a potential lawsuit. Sooner or later, landowners will die and their descendents will want to move somewhere else. The government, on the other hand, can afford to wait for years, decades, even centuries.
- barney54 11y agoThat is the story of Shenandoah National Park. It was created through eminent domain in the 1920s and 1930s and poor people were evicted off their land: http://fff.org/explore-freedom/article/eminentdomain-origin-shenandoah-national-park/ http://fff.org/explore-freedom/article/eminentdomain-origin-... http://www.dailykos.com/story/2009/05/27/735042/-These-Hills-Were-Once-Home-A-Shenandoah-National-Park-Photo-Diary http://www.dailykos.com/story/2009/05/27/735042/-These-Hills...
- jonah 11y agoI was just visiting Glacier National Park last month and the stories surrounding private landowners inside the boundaries of the park are pretty colorful. http://missoulian.com/lifestyles/territory/private-land-inside-glacier-national-park-passes-through-generations-of/article_94751fc6-6a9c-11df-b66f-001cc4c002e0.html http://missoulian.com/lifestyles/territory/private-land-insi... http://billingsgazette.com/news/state-and-regional/montana/glacier-national-park-buys-acres-of-private-land-inside-boundaries/article_4f769d99-b8ae-5af7-9859-617c23657610.html http://billingsgazette.com/news/state-and-regional/montana/g... http://news.heartland.org/newspaper-article/2002/11/01/promises-promises-promises http://news.heartland.org/newspaper-article/2002/11/01/promi... http://landrights.org/mt/glac/mcfarland.htm http://landrights.org/mt/glac/mcfarland.htm For example.
- nmcveity 11y agoI was in Grand Teton a few months ago. It has 110 private inholdings[1] and our guide talked a length about them. You drive by a few of them on the road north of Jackson Hole. Just the drive-by made me think that these must be some of the most desirable properties in the US. There were also interesting stories regarding the formation of the park [2]. An interesting story, for sure, but it also helps illuminate why there are inholdings in the park in the first place. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Teton_National_Park https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Teton_National_Park [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snake_River_Land_Company https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snake_River_Land_Company
- calinet6 11y agoAcadia (http://npmaps.com/wp-content/uploads/acadia-map.jpg http://npmaps.com/wp-content/uploads/acadia-map.jpg) has always been an example of this for me, both in how many private lands like this exist in National Parks, and of the striking difference between the east coast and the west in land ownership and attitude. It's dotted with and surrounded by private land, despite being a natural wonder in the class of Yosemite or Yellowstone in grandeur and uniqueness. At certain points, you drive over bridges that cross golf courses, and you can't help but wonder whether this Disneyland nature park isn't also inextricable from its web of humanity and history. The west is still wild, and it's a human wonder that we've managed to keep it that way. I'm glad for public land. Its value to our society is truly immeasurable.
- douche 11y agoPeople have lived more or less continuously on Mount Desert Island since the end of the Seven Years War (It was in something of a DMZ between French Acadia and British Massachusetts, and everyone that tried to settle there soon got burned out by one side or the other). The only reason that the park exists is that it became a resort town for the Gilded Age tycoons, and they bought up all the land that makes up the park, because they didn't want anyone industrying up their summering place. Most of the palatial mansions burned in a wildfire in the 40s, and the tourism has a more middle-class flavor these days, but there's still a huge distinction between the natives and the summer people. I always enjoyed Baxter State Park more. Up there, if you get off the AT, you might not see a person for days, unless you come out on a road and a log truck happens by.
- DiabloD3 11y agoI live in Ellsworth (15 minutes from Bar Harbor, you have to drive through Ellsworth to get to any part of Acadia National Park). You're overlooking a large part of the history: most of the park was donated land that was owned by the Rockefellers, of which they continually have grown the park over the past 50 years. The park doesn't have islands in it as much as the park ate up all the land AROUND these islands, making the islands exist in the first place. I suspect Acadia is the only national park that is growing at the rate it has over the decades.
- cjslep 11y agoI was surprised this past summer to see even Cape Lookout National Seashore in North Carolina has an occasional odd private house, for example on Long Point Island. It's a park with almost no presence on the continental U.S. and almost entirely on Outer Bank islands and feels like being on the edge of the world. Kayaking past two such houses sound-side was rather unexpected!
- WalterBright 11y agoThe national parks are a success that is indescribable in its value and enormity. We should be doing the same with some of the coastal waters. Those areas need to ban all fishing and motorized boats. At the least, they will serve as reservoirs of wildlife that can repopulate the rest of the overfished areas.
- linkydinkandyou 11y agoWhy do you think the national parks are a great evil?
- cdcarter 11y agoHe thinks the opposite.
- asheldon 11y agoEnormity means great evil.
- sgc 11y agoThat is its first definition, not its only one. It is regularly used to simply mean immense.
- linkydinkandyou 11y ago"Gay" is regularly used to mean "stupid" but we would call out someone on HN that uses it that way.
- xlm1717 11y agoThis is stupid...
- tempestn 11y agoNational parks are fantastic and extremely valuable. This fund has probably provided enormous long-term value. I do take issue with these statements though: > The Land and Water Conservation Fund isn’t taxpayer-funded. Since 1964, the government has redirected money from offshore oil and gas drilling (plus a couple other sources of income) into the fund... > It’s striking to see how much land has been added by the program, at no cost to taxpayers. In reality, government revenue is fungible. If this fund didn't exist, that revenue would go toward other government expenses. So saying that it's funded by X revenue and therefore costs nothing to taxpayers is just mental accounting.
- caf 11y agoThere's a word for that mental accounting: hypothecation.
- corin_ 11y agoSimilar (kind of) concept but hypothecation is about collateral, not mental accounting, unless it has a second, different meaning too?
- caf 11y agoYes, there's a second meaning in relation to taxes / revenue where a particular tax or revenue source is notionally allocated to a particular set of spending.
- desas 11y agoIn the UK our approach to national parks is quite different, due to our history and population density. Most of the land inside them is privately held and they contain hamlets, villages, towns and lots of farmland. I'm not sure about other parks but the Peak District contains many quarries and factories too.
- notahacker 11y agoWe also have a different approach to private land though; within reason you can walk all over private agricultural land, and there are often rights of way through other private land which might otherwise block a walking route.