6 ms·
I see HN's ongoing War On Linkbait has resulted in the title of this being changed from the one presented on the article itself, "Why the Best War Reporter in a
by smacktoward 11y ago
I see HN's ongoing War On Linkbait has resulted in the title of this being changed from the one presented on the article itself, "Why the Best War Reporter in a Generation Had to Suddenly Stop." Which feels a little insulting to the reporter in question, the New York Times' C.J. Chivers, since it results in him getting demoted to just "a war reporter."
But the edit also manages to make the article sound much less interesting than it actually is! So mission accomplished, I guess?
- electricblue 11y agoI like this actually. Keep expectations low. Hyperbolic titles are the worst.
- dang 11y agoI don't agree that the edit makes the article sound less interesting, nor that it is insulting to take out superlatives, which we do routinely. It does make the title less catchy, of course; that's one reason we do it.
- teacup50 11y agoIn this case, a magazine of note specifically chose to label this individual "the Best War Reporter in a Generation". That's not a link-bait superlative; it's a statement of judgement relevant to the story. "Why a War Reporter Had to Suddenly Stop" is a very different headline for a very different story.
- dang 11y agoOn HN we don't simply accept what a "magazine of note" decides to tell us in its headline. Readers here can make up their own minds.
- mfoy_ 11y agoI thought on HN we didn't editorialize titles. (Unless it's for character count restrictions)
- dang 11y agoThe HN guideline is "Please use the original title unless it is misleading or linkbait." Does that answer your question?
- mfoy_ 11y agoFair enough, although I disagree that the title is link-bait.
- theoh 11y agoOne way to flag titles that you consider to be link bait would be to put quotation marks around them, as in "one weird trick that..." The proliferation of quotation marks would probably give the impression of a somewhat sarcastic and superior editorial policy, but in all seriousness, software people are all about detailed quotation policies, literal references where appropriate, changelogs, version control, etc. HN's stripped-down aesthetic is a bit Procrustean.
- zrail 11y agoIn general, sure. In this instance, this is a bad policy decision. The title of the article is substantiative. It only seems like link bait at the shallowest possible reading level.
- wdewind 11y ago> On HN we don't simply accept what a "magazine of note" decides to tell us in its headline. > Readers here can make up their own minds. These two sentences seem in conflict to me...
- dang 11y agoAccurate, neutral titles are what's best for readers to make up their own minds. Someone has to make the call about what an accurate, neutral title is, though—otherwise there would be a deadlock. In practice, it's not all that arbitrary—not algorithmic, but not wildly subjective either. We get it wrong sometimes, but the quality of the front page is vastly higher with this practice than it would be without it. You may also have noticed that when people complain about titles, in nearly every case we accommodate their complaints. I'm not doing that this time because the present case seems clear to me and worth defending on principle. But that's rare. Edit: we did change the title based on this suggestion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10235921 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10235921. It's really helpful when users suggest better titles! I wish it happened more often.
- wdewind 11y agoAs always thanks for a thoughtful reply. I'll reiterate somethings I've mentioned to you before: > Accurate, neutral titles are what's best for readers to make up their own minds. Not to be pedantic, but I think you are using the word accurate when you mean precise. Accuracy implies a consistent lens. My concern is that by striving for higher precision titles we lose a consistency that actually has less bias long term. > In practice, it's not all that arbitrary—not algorithmic, but not wildly subjective either. This is something that's been said over and over again to a community that is extremely focused on empirical evidence. It would be not only great to have a better understanding of how this works, it would be extremely interesting to the community. > You may also have noticed that when people complain about titles, in nearly every case we accommodate their complaints. I have noticed that, thank you. > I'm not doing that this time because the present case seems clear to me and worth defending on principle. But that's rare. Again, this is a group that responds very well to evidence based argument, and so it's kind of lame to hear that these decisions are made unilaterally based on your principles. I mentioned bias above. Systems that are based on one person making decisions based on their principles are by definition biased. Maybe this is fine, but in that case it would be nice if it was made more clear to the community. Anyway, don't feel obligated to respond to this, it's just feedback. I understand you're doing the best you can to solve a really hard problem, and I do appreciate the work you put in. It's clear you are thoughtful and working hard, but more transparency would be greatly appreciated.
- paganel 11y agoI didn't know said war reporter's name, but, granted, I don't usually read long war-related stories from the likes of the NYTimes or Esquire (I find them overly biased). Even so, calling him the "best war reporter in a generation" is a bit of an over-statement. He may be very talented, but as far as I know he didn't put online anything like guys like this did: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1rorjogZdwM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1rorjogZdwM (at 2:51 you can hear bullets flying just a couple of meters above him, microphone still in hand). Granted, what these guys in Syria do is not very smart, safety wise (no helmets, no anything), but they're doing war reporting by actually risking their lives almost every day. Also, they're not "Westerners" and shout "Allah akbar", so that may have something to say about their job not being recognized as "the best in a generation".
- btilly 11y agoWhat makes a war reporter good is not that they do crazy shit, it is that they do a good job of reporting important stuff. Unraveling the supply chains behind the bombs is an example of reporting important stuff.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rgbrenner 11y agoI agree with you dang, but the title is a bit vague. A random war reporter quitting isn't interesting. I clicked on the link to scan over it, and was surprised to see it was CJ Chivers, and ended up reading the entire article. Maybe a better title would be "Why War Reporter CJ Chivers Had to Suddenly Stop" but I suppose the name doesn't add anything if you don't think people will recognize his name.
- dang 11y agoOk, we'll use your title. Thanks! I'd push back a bit here though: > A random war reporter quitting isn't interesting. An article about an unknown reporter might well be more interesting (in HN's sense) than an article about a famous one. That is a function of the article, not the fame of its subject.
- rgbrenner 11y agoThanks for pushing back on that point. I realized that part was a mistake a couple hours after posting it. HN would be a lot less interesting if we only had articles from famous people/companies/etc. (BTW, I appreciate the transparency and openness your posts bring to HN. I know that can't always be easy, but you're doing an awesome job.)
- dang 11y agoThat's really nice of you to say, and I'm grateful.
- jschwartzi 11y agoDo you think C.J. Chivers might be the type of person to get upset over being "demoted" to "just 'a war reporter?'" The type of person the article reveals him to be suggests that it might not bother him all that much.
- LordKano 11y agoIt's certainly better than "One weird trick to stop reporting on wars" or "War profiteers hate this man, find out why".
- meatysnapper 11y agoPersonally, I see the Buzfeed-ification of titles as an art form. Appreciate it while it lasts; we will be nostalgic for this soon.
- legohead 11y agowas his title before the demotion, "Best War Reporter"?
- hyperpallium 11y agoIt's funny, the current title "Why War Reporter C.J. Chivers Had to Suddenly Stop" struck me as click-bait. Why not say why, so we don't have to click to find out? War reporter C.J. Chivers had to suddenly stop because of PTDS.
- hyperpallium 11y agoIt's funny, the current title "Why War Reporter C.J. Chivers Had to Suddenly Stop" struck me as click-bait. Why not say why, so we don't have to click to find out? "War reporter C.J. Chivers had to suddenly stop because of PTSD." But I note that HN titles only get changed after they hit the frontpage - after clickbait has done its work.