3 ms·
It is interesting to here of situations where traditional oral histories line up with scientific measurement. It's a fun topic. But after a while these articl
by sandworm101 11y ago
It is interesting to here of situations where traditional oral histories line up with scientific measurement. It's a fun topic. But after a while these articles give the false impression that oral traditions are somehow trustworthy. Few ever talk about where the oral history is fundamentally incorrect. It always seems that the scientific discovery comes first, that the oral confirmation is just window dressing in the press release. Is the "extraordinary thing" of confirmation the norm? How many oral histories were disproved during this research?
These articles also tend to polish out the rough edges. How exactly did this people fleeing the rising water levels "negotiate" with peoples in the interior? Was this controlled mediation? Or does the term "negotiate" also cover outright war between cultures? Perhaps part of the reason these stories survived was the bloodshed surrounding their creation. I'd like to see the transcripts.