7 ms·
The headline reminds me of Feynman's account of teaching physics in Rio. Every student could stand and deliver a verbatim retelling of all the definitions in t
by stcredzero 17y ago
The headline reminds me of Feynman's account of teaching physics in Rio. Every student could stand and deliver a verbatim retelling of all the definitions in the textbook. They had just covered polarized light. The classroom had a beautiful view of the bay, with sunlight glinting off the water.
Feynman asks for and gets a recitation about polarized light, which includes a bit about reflected light being polarized. He then turns towards the window and asks the class for an example of polarized light. The whole class is flummoxed. Everyone could recite, but none of them could apply.
EDIT: I remember the day, being a TA for a Comp Sci 101 class, when I realized that a lot of the most vocal and active members of the class were more interested in the mechanics of lectures and tests than the material. It was all a game. I put stuff on the blackboard and in the handouts, and they spit it out on the test sheet. We have become a society of appearances and bureaucratic mechanism. Most college students go through the motions and get their paper, then go home thinking science is just more made up bullshit like politics. These folks laugh when you talk about evolution as reality, and can only reason abstractly at the level of a grade schooler. Many of them graduate, vote, and get promoted to positions of authority.
- dschobel 17y agoI'll never forget when I was interviewing a candidate for a junior C# programming position and the conversation went as follows: me: Can you tell me what a delegate is? candidate: <text-book perfect definition, absolutely flawless> me: Great! Can you tell me when you would ever want to use one? candidate: <silence for about 15 seconds> I don't know. It was so bizarre and I still don't fully understand how you can understand the absolutely perfect theoretical definition with having no, literally not one, idea what you're learning.
- snprbob86 17y agoPersonally, I simply cannot _recall_ anything unless I understand it at least superficially. I may be able to _remember_ if prompted, but my memory is simply organized around my own definitions and understanding. Maybe us engineering types are hardwired this way. I suspect, however, that non-engineering types aren't wired this way due to poor parenting, weak schools, and fundamentally broken reward and punishment systems.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- CWuestefeld 17y agoI simply cannot _recall_ anything unless I understand it at least superficially Me too. That's why the wheels came off my math skills when I got to differential equations. Everything up to that point I'd been able to form a picture of in my head. For example, calculus is just Newtonian mechanics, so that's got a clear analog in the real world. But Diff EQ was just too abstract. I was eventually able to pass it with the help of a couple friends pumping me full of formulas and procedures, but I never really understood, and so I never could really apply it on my own.
- ShardPhoenix 17y agoDifferential equations often map to physical scenarios - waves, heat diffusion, etc.
- timwiseman 17y agoVery true, they are incredibly useful. But as taught in most class rooms the application is far removed from the instruction. A differential equations class is often not much more than showing some techniques and then assigning numerous quantative problems that use those techniques. So, taking a differential equations class by itself can make it seem abstract and with limited connection to the physical world.
- ahlatimer 17y agoI have had the same experience in a lot (all?) of my math classes. I never really understood integrals and differentiation until I saw them come up in a physics class. Once I saw the practical application of those things, I didn't have much of an issue in actually solving them. That's the primary reason why I hate math courses. I know there are practical applications to everything I'm learning, but I just can't see them.
- 17y ago
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- NathanKP 17y agoFor me I am the exact opposite. You might ask me what a delegate is and I might say, "Uh... I don't remember." Yet it is something that I use every day in my programming, I just don't usually think of it as being a delegate. I was fascinated when I took my first C++ class and learned that using a pointer was called referencing and dereferencing. I had been using C++ for years on my own and had always thought of it as: x = &y; //X equals the address of Y. x = *y; //X equals the value at the address Y. To me that made more sense than calling it "referencing" and "dereferencing".
- ams6110 17y agoExactly the same. I also never really thought that pointers were difficult yet it seems to be a major stumbling block for many beginning C programmers. Perhaps having already done assembly language programming before I learned C was the reason.
- NathanKP 17y agoRight, in that same class most of the rest of the students simply could not seem to understand pointers. They asked me, a fellow student, questions like "Why would you ever use pointers?" The thing was, I think my lack of "jargon" made me explain the answer better than the professor did. Hence the other students asked me, not the professor. It seems to me that fancy terminology such as "referencing" and "dereferencing" is not only not common sense, but it also makes it harder to understand things when you are starting out. Perhaps as professional programmers it makes it easier to talk about algorithms between each other, but jargon is generally for the sake of exclusivity, not for the sake of convenience. I would even go so far as to suggest that anything that can be said with jargon can probably be said better with simple language. What beginning programmers are learning these days is jargon, and the definition of jargon terms, but they aren't learning what the meaning of those terms is. There is a big difference between learning the definition of something and learning its meaning.
- ramchip 17y agoAs you say using it early into an intro programming class may be a mistake, but it's soon useful in that you can say 'don't dereference b, it might be null' instead of something like 'don't attempt to read the data located at address b, b might be a null pointer'. Are you sure about 'referencing' though? I've never heard it in this context. It could be confusing given how C++ has references has well.
- ajb 17y agoSometimes it works the other way round. One professor solved an equation in a class by integrating with respect to pi. The students could not believe their eyes: "You can't do that!", they said; "pi is a constant!". The professor explained that once you have expressed your problem in a formal system like mathematics, you can do anything that is allowed in the rules of that system, even if the intermediate stages make no sense with respect to the original problem, and still obtain a correct answer. [This story is from E T Jaynes 'Probability theory, the logic of science'. But I don't have it to hand, so I may have the details wrong (and I can't remember who the prof was - it wasn't Jaynes).]
- sown 17y agoIt's absolutely a game. I spent most of my college years doinking around with hacker wargames and trying to hack kernel code, albeit not well. I didn't get graded on that but rather on how well I could put together a resume or whatever. I realized at that time that my "grades" would suffer if I didn't "work" harder at it but I made a conscience decision to hack more. I did as much as was required to graduate and did what I wanted the rest of the time.
- jeromec 17y ago> Most college students go through the motions and get their paper, then go home thinking science is just more made up bullshit like politics. But I don't see how anyone can come to a conclusion that "science is just more made up bullshit" when the application of science can be, and has been, practically demonstrated to be accurate, in cases such as sending people to the moon, a lander to mars, and even detonating an atomic bomb.
- DougBTX 17y agoSending people to the moon and the atomic bomb were as much political as scientific. Without politics, I doubt either would have happened when they did.
- jeromec 17y agoThe topic of politics has no bearing whatsoever on my statement of incredulity that any sane person could draw such a conclusion as to think science is bullshit. The text could have read "...thinking science is just more made up bullshit like [Santa Claus]" for all I care.
- ams6110 17y agoI once had a girlfriend who thought that way. Thought that going to the moon was a complete waste of resources because it "made no real difference in anyone's life"
- jeromec 17y agoWhether or not it was a waste of resources is not the point. The point is that science is what made going to the moon possible.
- walkon 17y agoThese folks laugh when you talk about evolution as reality, and can only reason abstractly at the level of a grade schooler. Since you tossed this subject in, how about folks that disagree with (macro)evolution but have a Ph.D. from MIT and currently work as a Nuclear Research Manager for NASA? http://www.apologeticspress.org/staff/mh http://www.apologeticspress.org/staff/mh I've met this guy and he does not reason like a grade schooler. Also, he noted that many of his colleagues agree with his position regarding origin science.
- tokenadult 17y agohow about folks that disagree with (macro)evolution but have a Ph.D. from MIT and currently work as a Nuclear Research Manager for NASA? I followed the link you kindly provided. I see this man's higher education was not majoring in subjects most likely to expose him to the evidence for biological evolution. Nor does the link list any peer-reviewed papers of his on any subject related to the evidence for biological evolution. Macroevolution is a fact http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/comdesc/ http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/comdesc/ in the same sense that nuclear fission is a fact. Neither is routinely directly observed with understanding by laymen, but both sets of facts can be demonstrated by experiment and are consistent with broader bodies of verified scientific knowledge.
- walkon 17y agoI brought him up as an example that there are certainly people out there that don't agree with macro evolution and can reason well beyond that of a "grade schooler." I was not trying to allege that he himself has done any research directly refuting origin evolution. Perhaps if origin evolution could come up with scientific theories that are falsifiable, we'd see more refuting research.
- tokenadult 17y agoI brought him up as an example that there are certainly people out there that don't agree with macro evolution and can reason well beyond that of a "grade schooler." Fair enough. And I brought up the evidence for macroevolution, http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/comdesc/ http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/comdesc/ in relation to the main point of the thread-opening submission, to show that college-educated persons with normal curiosity, reading ability, and access to the Internet should be well convinced that macroevolution is a fact, in the same way that nuclear fission is a fact. Perhaps the problem of someone who doubts macroevolution (as, in fact, I was once taught to do) is not a problem of reasoning ability at all, in agreement with you. (I thought my reasoning ability was just fine, and some forms of school testing including the GRE suggested that it was, before I became convinced by the evidence for macroevolution. But I had a crucial lack of curiosity when I wasn't looking up the evidence http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/comdesc/ http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/comdesc/ to use my reasoning ability to evaluate that evidence.) Now I'm curious about the puzzling pattern of upvotes and downvotes here. I think the concern about science education expressed in the thread-opening submission would be a general concern of HN participants, and I would think that a comment that posts a link to a source of reliable scientific conclusions in such a thread would not be considered a detriment to the quality of discussion on HN. Perhaps if origin evolution could come up with scientific theories that are falsifiable, we'd see more refuting research. Demonstrating my curiosity in what I hope is a friendly way, what kind of theories do you have in mind? What would be a way to falsify a theory (from any point of view) about origin of species?