4 ms·
But that's the point. How can a signature indicate the final version of a doc and provide basis for a lawsuit if the signature can't be verified as legitimate?
by colordrops 11y ago
But that's the point. How can a signature indicate the final version of a doc and provide basis for a lawsuit if the signature can't be verified as legitimate?
- SEMW 11y agoIt isn't providing the evidential basis, it's providing the legal basis. Ie the signature isn't used to authenticate in a public-key cryptography kind of way, it's being used as a legal trigger: 'if you write a name here that isn't yours, you are committing a criminal offence'. (How that offence is proved is a separate issue). Hence electronic signatures can be as simple as typing your name into a text box (or even just a checkbox). The (dubious) uniqueness of a handwritten signature is nonessential.
- rayiner 11y agoIn most every case, circumstantial evidence and witnesses can establish if the party that purportedly signed a document did in fact do so. The CEO of a company can't plausibly deny his signature on a contract when there are emails in evidence saying "let's get that contract signed tomorrow." So why do we bother to sign documents? Most of all, its a symbolic gesture intended to signal (to the parties and witnesses) the attachment of legal rights and obligations. It avoids disputes such as "yeah, he presented me with that document, but it was a proposal and I never agreed to it."
- antsar 11y ago> can't plausibly deny his signature on a contract when there are emails in evidence saying "let's get that contract signed tomorrow." Is this true? An email showing intent to sign a contract, combined with a signature that somewhat resembles my own, is sufficient proof for a court that I actually signed that contract? That seems somewhat crazy.
- rayiner 11y agoWhy does that seem crazy? Think about it statistically: you have evidence of intent to sign a contract, and a signed contract consistent with that evidence. In what percentage of cases was the contract actually not signed? Compare that to the burden of proof in a civil case--"more likely than not."
- antsar 11y agoI guess I assumed when they say "innocent until proven guilty", "proven" implies hard evidence, not just two facts that suggest that an event occurred.
- rdtsc 11y agoYeah but "proven guilty" in a civil case is a different set of criteria than in a criminal case.
- peterwwillis 11y agoIn most cases, there is no video tape, and almost never an actually smoking gun. "Proof" is whatever sounds reasonable to a judge or jury. It's also why our justice system is flawed: we sentence people without incontrovertible evidence all the time.
- tptacek 11y agoDefendants have a presumption of innocence, but accusers do not have a burden of mathematical proof. The closest you get to "innocent until proven guilty" in US law is common law's Ei incumbit probatio qui dicit, and the Latin word "probatio" does a lot more work than just "mathematical proof". There's a good 30 minute Google jag you can have about this if you go search for [legal standards of proof].
- rayiner 11y ago> The closest you get to "innocent until proven guilty" in US law is common law's Ei incumbit probatio qui dicit, and the Latin word "probatio" does a lot more work than just "mathematical proof". TIL.
- jdmichal 11y agoCoincidentally, that's exactly the problem that notaries solve.
- rdtsc 11y agoThere are other things for signatures than just notaries. There is a "medalion signature guarantee" in which case certifying institution will be on the hook so to speak if they don't go the extra step to verify who is signing. They will usually ask for multiple ids, and will keep copies of them for records. Most people just never have to deal with that, it is kind of a obscure service that few bank provide these days to the public: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medallion_signature_guarantee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medallion_signature_guarantee