4 ms·
You obviously have not read the paper that they are summarizing. Else you'd not have brought up a point that they addressed directly and came up with strong ev
by btilly 17y ago
You obviously have not read the paper that they are summarizing. Else you'd not have brought up a point that they addressed directly and came up with strong evidence against.
In different times and places there have been many terrorist organizations who are supporting different kinds of causes. Engineers are significantly overrepresented in right wing religious ones, and are virtually nonexistent in various left wing ones.
Were it a simple case of selective reporting and economics then you would not see a correlation between the profession involved in the terrorist organization and the cause that organization is for. But there is a strong correlation, and therefore something deeper is happening than us noticing engineers because their skills and economic status make them useful to terrorists.
- roc 17y agoI hadn't read the whole paper, no. The article went only as far as suggesting that right-wing ideologies appealed more to the engineering mindset. And I'm hardly convinced that any given extremist ideology is more, or less, seeking to bring order and unambiguity to the world. That the summary went on to note that fundamentalist extremists were actively recruiting engineers didn't exactly help the argument that the over-representation is a natural result of mind-sets. All things being equal, perhaps there are more engineers willing to kill for Allah than ELF. But the summary in that article is so unconvincing that I'm not particularly motivated to spend time with the paper.