11 ms·
I’m Ahmed. Except I’m Not Brown
- wheaties 11y agoI'm glad he said this is a problem with America and not just Texas. Zero tolerance is hurting kids with bringing scissors to school or handing Advil out for headaches. It's probably one of the most distructive policies we could ever have.
- userbinator 11y ago"zero tolerance" is more like "zero thinking".
- apricot 11y agoZero conscience.
- redblacktree 11y agoWhat they're hoping for is "zero liability"
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- MrZongle2 11y agoIt's "zero responsibility": any administrator can simply point to the "zero tolerance" policy and claim to be following the established rules. It's entirely a CYA measure for staff, and has nothing to do with the well-being of students.
- sjs382 11y ago"zero culpability"
- mindslight 11y agoThe original term is utterly appropriate. "Zero tolerance of differing perspectives" sums up contemporary USian thought. (ding ding ding! we have some winners!)
- gloves 11y agoI'd like to think the overwhelming majority of people share your complete disdain and frustration at this terrible story. Racism is a problem, and we should be discussing it out in the open, facing it head on.
- austenallred 11y agoIt's difficult how much of this is a race issue and how much if it is a zero tolerance issue. At first I wanted to say, "If he were white today the same thing would have happened," but the more I imagine a nerdy white kid with circuit board in a case, the more I think that race played a big role.
- tedks 11y agoI'm white and I got suspended because people on the hockey team who had been bullying me for years alleged I owned books containing bomb-making instructions. It took my mom arguing my case in a special meeting with the principal, a rep from the district, and a guidance counselor to get claims of anti-semetism removed from my record (because I was and am an atheist and had expressed the viewpoint that religion was a social ill). If I had brought to school what Ahmed did, I probably would have been dropped with two to the chest and one in the head by the school cop and then double-tapped on the ground. Maybe I just would have been tased, handcuffed, arrested, and recommended for expulsion as per the school district's zero tolerance policy, but since I had long hair and wore lots of black clothing at the time my school probably regarded me as the most likely Columbine copycat candidate and would have reacted appropriately. Ironically, this was in an affluent area with plenty of wealthy foreigners living in the US. There were a few Muslim students at my school, and aside from juvenile idiots I'm sure there was almost no islamophobia, and certainly none on the institutional level. But everyone has stereotypes they fear, and if you fall into that as a child in the school system god help you.
- generic_user 11y agoHow does an imagining of a nerdy white kid provided you with some factual evidence this story has anything to do with ethnicity. These stories happen now and then. Its ridiculous yes, but don't fall for identity politics click bait nonsense.
- austenallred 11y agoI obviously have no evidence to back this up, (I'm not sure what evidence there could possibly be outside of a long psychology study) but I could imagine a white kid in my High School getting away with it while an Arab was instantly questioned. I live in a very, very conservative area, where minorities are given a lot of crap.
- JohnTHaller 11y agoCircuit board and wires? Must be a bomb. - Texas teachers and police 2015 D cell batteries and LED lights? Must be a bomb. - Boston police 2007
- apricot 11y agoSpeaking of which, Star Simpson tweeted yesterday: "I hope Ahmed finds the community he seeks at MIT — & I hope MIT's administration can support future engineers in need of legal protection."
- abalos 11y agoOne thing that people haven't been pointing out enough is that the administrators didn't make the mistake when they questioned Ahmed about this device. If there's even the smallest chance that it could cause harm, they need to investigate. What they did wrong is everything after they learned that it wasn't harmful or anything resembling a weapon. They should have apologized and then sent him on his merry way. Instead, they're doubling down on this "no tolerance" BS and taking it out on a kid who has done nothing to deserve it. It's ridiculous. /endrant
- tedks 11y agoBut it DID resemble a weapon. According to zero tolerance policies, a chicken finger can resemble a weapon: http://articles.latimes.com/2001/feb/01/news/mn-19819 http://articles.latimes.com/2001/feb/01/news/mn-19819 This was made very clear to me when I went to high school (from 2004-2009). If you had a gun, or a toy gun, or two pieces of wood nailed at a right angle and held like a gun, and you so much as brought it onto the school grounds, you would be handed over to the police and recommended for expulsion. I'm 100% sure that next week, at least one high school kid will be expelled for something like this. It won't make the news, because there won't be a fleet of outraged tumblr users to champion the kid, because he won't have a name like Ahmed Mohammed. Probably he'll be black, because hey, school to prison pipeline has to pump, but he could just as easily be white. It's not like the school administrators have any leeway in enforcing district policy. The principal would get fired if he just went "Well, you brought something that we have to expel you for, but you're a good kid, don't do it again." That's how you get favoritism and corruption and it's not something we should try to encourage. Instead, we should attack the actual problem here, which is the zero tolerance policy. You can't get Donald Trump soundbytes about zero tolerance policies, but that's the actual problem.
- generic_user 11y agoI doubt they acted outside of there authority under the law. That does not mean the post 911 paranoia is reasonable, but the root problem is the Patriot Act style legislation. Administrators, Judges and Police have to fallow the law whether it makes sense or not there is just as big a chance the administrators get a lawsuit from over protective paranoid parents then the reverse. The authors trying to shoehorn this story into identity politics is unfortunately predicable click bait at this point. It just detracts form the actual issue which is overboard paranoid legislation which makes these incidents more likely.
- knivets 11y ago> If I had been a black kid? No way. I can’t imagine that the teachers of a white, white, white suburban Boston high school would have patted me on the head for all of that. Opening unlocked doors would have been taken as breaking and entering. If I told them that I’d put in a lot of time to decipher the mechanical workings of a common school lock and how to exploit its weaknesses, they’d have assumed the only reason I’d have gone to all of that trouble was because I planned to steal stuff, not because I was intellectually excited by an intriguing puzzle. Too polarized and emotional. There is a problem, yes. But that doesn't mean that all teachers will treat a black or brown child differently from the white one. And also America is not the worst case. Here in Ukraine almost everyone hates black and brown people.
- cpcat 11y agoalmost everyone? another sweeping generalisation?
- striking 11y agoWhen on vacation in Poland, I had the opportunity to meet some Ukrainian emigrants. And they asked me in Polish, in earnest: "...so, are black people dangerous? I hear there are a lot of them in America." They had never met a black person in real life. Your culture is different than theirs. Wolfram-Alpha agrees: they will likely never have met a black person. http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=black+people+in+ukraine http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=black+people+in+ukraine
- david-given 11y agoAbsolutely. (Although bear in mind that the term 'African-American' for someone with brown skin is American-centric, and other countries don't use it. Luckily WA understood you.) On the other side of the coin, while visiting Dallas on work from Europe, I was asked, quite seriously, whether I was worried about the the Muslim campaign to control Europe by outbreeding the natives (or something, I'm not good at remembering this stuff). I don't think they'd ever met a Muslim in their life.
- daktanis 11y agoIm from a very white, rural town. In 2005 I was a Junior and a kid got suspended for bringing a 3 foot section of 2x4 to school. He was white. We live in a zero tolerance time, Ahmed brought a bundle of electronics and a ticking clock. It wasn't a good idea. Should it have been handled better? Yes, of course. But we live in a shitty time where two yahoos can learn to make a bomb online and cause mass destruction (see Boston Marathon Bombing).
- daktanis 11y agoWhen I was in middle school I found a note on the ground while walking to my next class with writings about how this person hated the school and wanted to blow it up. I was 12, I didnt think much of it and handed it off to a nosy friend who wanted to read it too. Well she turned it in and said I found it, I was interrogated (at the school to be fair) for an hour and half by the principle and a police office without once having called my parents. Zero tolerance man.
- afarrell 11y agoA kid can cut out the pages from a book and hide a circuitboard in a book. Should we ban books from schools? No. A kid can put a piece of benign electronics in a backpack and just leave it in a crowded area without telling anyone.should we ban backpacks from schools? No. The answer to stupid overreaction isn't to say that benign educational activities are stupid; It is to stop overreaction.
- daktanis 11y agoIm sorry, was I approving the overreaction? No. Im saying I don't think its truly race motivated and that a High schooler should be knowledgable enough to know how it may appear. Maybe he could have left it with his shop teacher or gotten a note from the teacher. The teacher would have saved the kid some trouble since the teacher obviously thought it wouldn't be great if another teacher saw it. Imagine if it was a bomb how the media would be damning the school for not acting.
- JoeAltmaier 11y ago
- ianstallings 11y agoThis is kind of reaching to be honest.
- generic_user 11y agoThere is zero evidence this story has anything to do with the child's ethnicity except the insinuation from a Tech Crunch article to stir up clicks. This fallow on Blog post is silly, American style race baiting and hyperbole. The post 911 Patriot Act paranoia of the American authorities is ridiculous, but pleas do not get sucked in by click bait demagogues. There is no bottom the stupidity when it comes to these stories. There has been several cringe worthy stories of this type in the past few years about people with "homemade gadgets". http://tech.mit.edu/V127/N40/simpson.html http://tech.mit.edu/V127/N40/simpson.html
- Borogravia 11y agoHi generic_user - It looks like you're trying to make a "LALALA IT'S NOT RACISM UNLESS SOMEONE'S ACTUALLY WEARING A KLAN HOOD" argument. Do you want some help with that?
- peterwwillis 11y agoThis is not just a "brown" vs "non-brown" issue. When I was in school, I was almost arrested at my school for having phreaker box diagrams in my backpack, which was searched illegally (do kids in public school actually have privacy rights anyway?) by police after an unrelated complaint. I was unfairly targeted this way many times in different schools. I am as white as they come. This is not a brown vs non-brown issue; all schools treat their intelligent, inquisitive students like criminals. I say this having attended five different middle + high schools, public, magnet and private.
- ams6110 11y agoNo, students in school have minimal privacy rights particulary when it comes to searches. And that's not new.
- kuschku 11y agoI am so happy to be in Germany. A teacher once asked me to give her my phone (we were forbidden to use phones in school), so I put it in my bag and closed it. She instantly went to the director, who then started to discuss it with me (after 45 minutes of him shouting at me in a hallway, which had become a public attraction, he gave up), but at no point did anyone try to access my bag. The fact that my parents studied law might have something to do with it, though, so I’m not sure if other people would have been treated the same.
- xname 11y agoThis kind of zero tolerance thing does not necessarily have anything to do with racism. There are lots of examples happen to white kids too. http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2013/03/02/7-year-old-boy-reportedly-suspended-after-making-a-gun-out-of-a-pastry-at-school/ http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2013/03/02/7-year-old-boy-re... http://newsfeed.time.com/2013/03/04/watch-boy-suspended-from-school-for-making-gun-out-of-a-pop-tart/ http://newsfeed.time.com/2013/03/04/watch-boy-suspended-from... http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2012/02/26/dad-arrested-strip-searched-after-daughter-draws-a-picture-of-a-gun-in-school/ http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2012/02/26/dad-arrested-stri... http://toprightnews.com/13-year-old-boy-draw-caused-school-suspend-call-police/ http://toprightnews.com/13-year-old-boy-draw-caused-school-s... http://dailycaller.com/2014/05/24/teacher-asks-second-graders-to-draw-what-they-see-in-clouds-boy-sees-gun-teacher-writes-up-boy/ http://dailycaller.com/2014/05/24/teacher-asks-second-grader...
- jperras 11y agoIf the school administration was so certain it was a bomb, why was the building not evacuated immediately? For the threat they're making it out to be, they sure didn't act as if they believed it themselves.
- jimktrains2 11y agoThat's what I've always loved about the "random" screenings at security lines in the airport. "We need you to turn on your laptop." and "Give us your bag so that we can swab it" are inane. If you think it's a bomb, everyone should be removed and no one should be allowed to touch it, at all. It's all just theater and no one gives a damn. It's sad.
- fernandotakai 11y agomy wife always asked me why i called TSA a farce. last month we were coming back to brazil from denver, when her backpack was flagged for "inspection". when i asked the TSA officer why, she was quite polite and said "the x-ray inspector said there's a water bottle on her backpack". we were 100% sure that there was nothing like that because we triple checked before getting into the line. when the 'inspector' looked at her bag and the x-ray image on the monitor, it was not the same bag. the x-ray guy marked the wrong bag for inspection and the bag with the water bottle was already gone. the inspector apologized and let us go. my wife's question after we were gone was: "if they think water bottles could be bombs, shouldn't they close the airport?" now she knows why TSA is a farce.
- PirateDave 11y agoThis was posted on HN not too long ago, but further proof they're useless: http://abcnews.go.com/US/exclusive-undercover-dhs-tests-find-widespread-security-failures/story?id=31434881 http://abcnews.go.com/US/exclusive-undercover-dhs-tests-find...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- powertower 11y agoCan anyone explain how you can immediately attribute any of this to outright racism and his brown skin, when the staff and students are predominantly non-white in that school. School body is 86% non-white: http://www.usnews.com/education/best-high-schools/texas/districts/irving-independent-school-district/macarthur-high-school-19313/student-body http://www.usnews.com/education/best-high-schools/texas/dist... And in the entire disctrict, whites are 12%, and "browns" are 70%. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irving_Independent_School_District#Demographics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irving_Independent_School_Dist...
- nolite 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamophobia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamophobia
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mindslight 11y agoRacism is currently fashionable in the press and it plays to a core progressive narrative. The people doing so mean well, but unfortunately don't realize the price of this intellectual laziness is to completely alienate anybody else. People mostly care about problems that apply to themselves, so framing a problem as happening to "others" is actually extremely counter productive. PS: read for understanding instead of just trying to stoke your fauxrage.
- Floegipoky 11y agoI think people are downvoting you because of your implied suggestion that the issue of racism in the US should be approached from the perspective of white people, which is pretty messed up.
- mindslight 11y agoHow, exactly, is it "pretty messed up" ? I'd think if your goal was to convince the majority of something, you would look for ways to convince that majority of something. Like perhaps that their own kids could very well be arrested and traumatized in exactly this manner. Reducing racism gets us more "benefit of the doubt" that might have resolved the situation informally. But it does nothing to change school administrators thinking that turning a 14 year old over to the police on a whim is an appropriate thing to do. In this specific case I'm just glad this kid is actually innocent so that he can hopefully disassociate the event from himself and see that the school and police are horribly broken. Imagine if the arrest had been "justified" for accidentally bringing a pocket knife or aspirin to school - what kind of lasting psychological damage does that cause?
- dspeyer 11y agoFrom the article: > I’m angry, and I’m a little upset with myself because I want to be useful. I'm thinking the same thing. What I'm wishing is that I held a position of influence at a private high school, so I could offer him immediate entrance and a full scholarship. Mostly to correct the injustice, but also because he's clearly a top student: unassisted home-made clock trumps perfect SSATs. So if anybody reading this has such a position -- even a little bit -- please try to make it happen.
- throwaway1967 11y agoIt seems that clock only took him 20 minutes to make, the night before. He's made other things as well that are impressive. He makes his own radios and fixes his go-kart. Lots of potential there. As for me, if flushing the toilet doesn't help, I need to call someone.
- linuxkerneldev 11y agoSadly, Ahmed is being taught a lesson that all minorities in the US learn as part of growing up. Just like African American kids are taught to be terrified of the police and other authorities. If they behave the same as white kids or make similar assumptions about how the power structure interacts with them, then they're going to get murdered or punished in unfair ways.
- tmaly 11y agoThis made me think about a book I had read where it stated Humans are very bad at estimating risk. I think it could have been Nate Silver's book The Signal and Noise. It might have even been the Black Swan by Nassim Taleb
- ashwinaj 11y agoIt is Nassim Taleb. The irony is, with his name he would've been rounded up in the same school just like Ahmed.
- ambiate 11y agoIn my very similar case, I was suspended and subsequently offered to be sued or to quit school by the school board in my Mississippi hometown (100-200k pop). It was in 11th grade in 2002-2003. My mother was not even involved. I quit, because we were a poor family raking in $600/mo. Sue was an unfathomable word. Things worked out for me, but that's dumb luck. My criminal case? I ran the ping -t from a windows cmd prompt to see if an IRC server (I administrated) had rebooted. Screenshot evidence of my hardship on their servers and the 'attack' on my own server could not be argued. My earlier suspension (1064 pop town in MS) was for bringing a flute made from cane to school. It was a project item for art where we had to make a musical instrument. The cane was considered a physical assault device. I was suspended, had to walk home, and faced 3 months of Saturday school. My art teacher was the one who claimed it was a weapon. My wife was driven home by the school principal (alone at 14) in the first town because she 'appeared drugged', and no parents were there and she was left on the porch. She was given a Benadryl for allergies. She was suspended afterwards.
- jbattle 11y agonauseating. how long did it take you to trust "grownups" again (if ever)?
- ambiate 11y agoI do not really have this association due to the events that took place with the ping scenario. I just assumed they felt they were doing the right thing and negating any side effects from something that was misunderstood. The flute situation on the other hand seems like an almost personal attack, but that's just petty nonsense that quickly fades with time. My wife's scenario (and various others) still has an impact to this day.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ashwinaj 11y agoLet's not pretend that his name had nothing to do with it; it's all cute acting PC but let's get real. I've lived in Texas and the racism/segregation is very subtle but it's there (generally speaking). I find it funny that as an outsider that Americans don't let their kids walk/play alone in their neighborhood because "they are so naive and innocent", and there are child/sexual predators out there. Yet they somehow believe the same kid named Ahmed (guilt by association?) can somehow conjure up a bomb.
- csorrell 11y agoDo we really have to spin everything into a race issue these days? I never got the sense that race had anything to do with Ahmed's story.
- Torgo 11y ago>There was never any negative fallout. Yes, partly because it was more than a decade before 9/11. Lede buried.