4 ms·
The intent is not to legally bind her, which it obviously wouldn't. Usually the idea of having a child sign too is the idea having a child explicitly agree make
by vidarh 11y ago
The intent is not to legally bind her, which it obviously wouldn't. Usually the idea of having a child sign too is the idea having a child explicitly agree makes them more likely to be invested in complying. Whether or not there's any evidence that works, I don't know, but it's not quite as stupid as it might seem at first glance.
- tdees40 11y agoUh, she's four.
- interpol_p 11y agoThis isn't a comment on whether the original scenario was ridiculous or not, but you'd be surprised by how incredibly aware very young people are. Even a three year old can easily understand the significance of signing something. Especially if you, as an adult, place importance on the ritual. Asking toddlers to promise things, to explicitly agree to future events, is a big part of preventing tantrums. Three year olds are very capable negotiators.
- Avenger42 11y ago> Especially if you, as an adult, place importance on the ritual. Yes, we adults really place a lot of importance in the ritual of "scroll to the bottom and click 'Agree'". (In case my point is missed in the snark, it's that adults will often sign whatever they're told to sign, especially if worded like "sign this or else you can't [X]", and kids will sign whatever they're told to sign by their parents. If parents were actually placing importance on only signing things that were necessary, there's no way they should let their 4-year-old sign anything that could remotely be considered important.)
- interpol_p 11y agoI agree that asking a four year old to sign something outside the context of a fun game is stupid. But I just wanted to make the point that four year old — or even a three year old — can totally understand the concept of signing something and a parent could even use it to enforce a future event (e.g., sign this bath time contract which means you must have a bath after dinner).
- code_sterling 11y agoNo, it's as stupid as it sounds and your trying to rationalize stupid. She's 4.
- Jedd 11y agoyou're, and he/she really isn't trying to rationalise it, just explain the thinking of the (stupid) people behind it. I don't think anyone is arguing that the child in question is 4.
- mikeash 11y ago"...it's not quite as stupid as it might seem at first glance." Sure sounds like rationalization to me.
- coldtea 11y ago>Usually the idea of having a child sign too is the idea having a child explicitly agree makes them more likely to be invested in complying. No, it doesn't. If anything, the opposite (if the child is a teenager). If it's 4 it's just stupid.
- caf 11y agoYou don't have much recent experience with actual four-year-olds, do you?
- barkingcat 11y agoIt is as stupid as it sounds. 4 year old will listen to instructions and if they disobey you take away toys or have silent time, etc. But signing something? That's just really stupid. It's not enforceable and not even understandable.
- interpol_p 11y agoWhile the scenario described does sound ridiculous, I disagree that it's "not even understandable." (My understanding is that you meant the four year old wouldn't understand?) Many toddlers younger than three could grasp the idea of signing something as a promise to do that thing in the future. A three or four year old could easily understand it.
- barkingcat 11y agosorry I meant not understandable as a blanket policy especially since this is at a school. I would expect the school (being a place with lots of teachers) to understand that you get the parent to sign the document - with legally enforceable terms that the parent is responsible for whatever the kid does. That's what a kindergarden - grade 8 elementary school field trip permission form looks like! I'm sure they've made and processed hundreds of thousands of these forms before. It's just not understandable why they wouldn't do something similar with this open house.
- Avenger42 11y agoUm, if my 4-year-old "signs" something, it will go like this: Me: "Scribble something on this line." Kid: scribbles Me: "Here's your stupid form." How would that get my kid "invested in complying" ?