6 ms·
A couple of questions occurred to me while reading this. I hope I can make my case diplomatically. Who's to say what a PhD program really entails? I understand
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
A couple of questions occurred to me while reading this. I hope I can make my case diplomatically.
Who's to say what a PhD program really entails? I understand that there are professional accreditation organizations. My question is simple: if I am the president of Newbonia, why can't I set up my universities to require 20 years of study before awarding a PhD? Or one year and a up-front payment of $30K? The implication here is that less studying and more bribery is always bad, but is that always the case? If you shaved 20% off the work of a "normal" PhD have you really defrauded anyone? How about 60%? If so, how about if you make your course more rigorous? If you made your programs require more work doesn't that now imply that other countries are defrauding their students?
If this is truly a multi-million-dollar business, and thousands of folks are getting these "fake" certifications, are there any stories of people who have been harmed by folks with fake diplomas? There was one case mentioned in the story -- a fake therapist. But I find that unconvincing. Where's the societal fallout from all this fakery? Is this a story about real people getting hurt by fake-accredited folks? Or is it a story about academics up in arms over people who got the same kind of degree without all the suffering they had to go through? It seems to me to be the latter. But I honestly don't know.
I'm a huge believer in education, although perhaps not formal certification programs, which I find too stilted and archaic. And I'm definitely no fan of people lying to each other. But I wonder if we haven't reached a point in many cases where the degree is just a bullshit piece of paper needed for job advancement. A social worker with a Master's degree is most likely not that far advanced over one with a 4-year degree. In fact, the one with the lesser degree might be much more effective in their job. It's just employers need something to differentiate the worker bees and degrees seem like a natural fit. It's stupid, the people who are asking for it know it's stupid, and the people who are getting it understand it's stupid too. On top of this, prices are going through the roof for these things. So people are just starting to treat it like the silliness that it is and buying their degrees off the internet.
Please don't think I am making a blanket case -- obviously a brain surgeon is not something you can fake. But for the 80% of cases? Where some external organization is requiring a piece of paper so you can move from line manager to section manager or something like that? If the cost continues to rise and the knowledge received isn't actually being put to use then diploma mills seem like a very natural and normal market response to me.
- mquander 17y agoWell, regarding your first point, credible organizations accrediting universities are the ones who are to say what a PhD program entails. These diploma mills are unaccredited (or accredited via corrupt organizations) and try to either hide, lie about, or whitewash that fact.