4 ms·
Vinyl is very heavily processed. The sound that ends up on the groove has the bass cut by up to 20dB, and the treble boosted by the same amount, because the nee
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
Vinyl is very heavily processed. The sound that ends up on the groove has the bass cut by up to 20dB, and the treble boosted by the same amount, because the needle can't move fast enough and far enough to reproduce a flat frequency response. (Google "RIAA curve" for details.)
The processing is reversed on playback in the preamp, but there's always a mismatch between the source EQ and the preamp EQ, so there's always some tonal distortion. And because the bass gets boosted so much there's added waveform distortion which increases with bass frequencies and makes the bass thicker.
Many turntables also have pitch instabilities.
Hence "vinyl sound."
So no - it's not even remotely accurate. Add scratches, crackles, and pops, groove deterioration - the needle causes enough friction to melt the plastic in the groove - and other artefacts, and it's really more of a lifestyle/collector thing than anything to do with accuracy.
Personally I have enough physical stuff already, and I want less, not more. So being able to store all my music on a hard drive in FLAC format makes me thankful the industry moved beyond vinyl.
- vasilipupkin 11y agoBut if you wanted that type of sound, you could record it digitally. There is no reason why that type of sound has to come from a vinyl analog record. Is there ?
- coldtea 11y agoAnd people DO do that: using several compression, old mikes, tube amps, EQing, recording techniques, etc to make digital releases sound like vinyl/low-fi of yore. In fact one of the hottest selling audio plugin categories are "tape saturation" (which mimic 2-inch tape distortions, not that far from mimicking vinul). E.g.: https://www.u-he.com/cms/satin https://www.u-he.com/cms/satin When it comes to vinyl, there's also other factors: the patina (crackle) etc, adds connection to the times you've played the record, the fragility and tactile feel, plus it's a physical, collectible artifact. Plus, at least for now, the fashion factor. While a audio-file collection will be useless in 20 years (already is with things like Spotify giving access to most music), a good condition LP will mostly increase in price. In 50 years? A current pressing could be worth $200 or more (especially since most bands do small 1000 units or less vinul pressings).
- vasilipupkin 11y agoI get that it's fashion. It just surprises me, given there is no reason for it, as far as the actual quality of the signal goes. I mean it's one thing if you are collecting antique vinyl from the 1930s or something. But collecting modern recordings just seems bizarre to me. I am not judging, I am just amused. Also, Spotify doesn't give you the same quality sound as an audiofile collection of CDs, due to compression
- coldtea 11y ago>I get that it's fashion. It just surprises me, given there is no reason for it, as far as the actual quality of the signal goes. I think one way to see it is that it being in vinyl (with all the romantic, old-music-industry, analog etc ideas it conveys) is also part of the signal. As in, the signal is not the pure musical signal, but also the cultural one (the vinyl being emotional, nostalgic, romanticized, fashionished, fetishised, etc). >Also, Spotify doesn't give you the same quality sound as an audiofile collection of CDs, due to compression That's just a matter of time and better broadband connections. For most people, given their speakers/headphones quality, it's more than enough.
- teh_klev 11y agoTo try and explain....it's like the difference between fake "stressed" furniture which inside is just mashed up Ikea woodchip with a veneer stuck to it and the real deal. There's also the joy and relaxation of kicking back and watching the vinyl spin on the table whilst playing, it's mesmerizing and hypnotic.
- coldtea 11y agoI guess that the world is split between fetishists (who enjoy the things for multiple levels) and functionalists (who enjoy them only for their core utility).
- vasilipupkin 11y agowell, I enjoy album art and browsing for music and remembering where I got it - all the reasons cited for buying vinyl. So, it's not just the pure functionality for me, either. But you can get all those same things with CDs as well. So, I do find the vinyl fashion perplexing.
- coldpie 11y agoI've been thinking about your question. I suppose one appeal for me is that I understand how vinyl works. Putting a CD in isn't that much different from hitting Play on your MP3 player: you queue up your song, hit play, and music just happens behind the scenes, you can't watch it. But with vinyl, you can see it in action. I occasionally just sit there and watch the needle and cartridge and tone arm move across the surface of the record, imagining how the tiny vibrations of the needle are transformed into electrical amplitude, increased by the amp and played out of speakers. It's fun and, today, novel to be able to understand a whole system like that and observe each part doing its task.
- vasilipupkin 11y agoI see. Does that account though for the dramatic growth in LP sales. I mean is that why most people buy LPs nowadays?
- coldtea 11y ago>So no - it's not even remotely accurate. No, but it can still be quite pleasant. Same way we like saturated constrasty pics or even distorted guitars. >Personally I have enough physical stuff already, and I want less, not more. OTOH, a vinyl collection makes for a nice rustic touch to a mostly empty, mostly-digital, minimalist house.
- vasilipupkin 11y agobut why not a CD collection?
- coldtea 11y agoBecause CD is banal -- not as romantic/collectible/historical as vinyl, and not as conventient as mp3.
- vasilipupkin 11y agothis is exactly what I don't get. Why is a CD made in 2015 less romantic than an LP made in 2015 ?
- geden 11y agoVinyl's awkwardness and the rituals around it are a way of expressing dedication to music and expression dedication to music is a way of differentiating yourself. Vinyl use (or often just purchase and displat) has become the mark of someone who takes music seriously / passionately. My experience is that many people, especially the young like to signal that way.
- luckydude 11y agoWhat do you all think about Neil Young's take?