6 ms·
Attitudes Shift on Paid Leave: Dads Sue, Too
- masterleep 11y agoJust what the economy needs: additional legal risk and associated expense for employing people.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoWhether you like it or not, the US economy is going to get first-world worker protections, even if it needs to be dragged kicking and screaming (GDP be damned).
- pnut 11y agoKicking and screaming is the only way US business forfeits anything. We fought a civil war over slavery, for god's sake.
- mhurron 11y ago"Americans can always be counted on to do the right thing … after they have exhausted all other possibilities."
- gnoway 11y agoThis is pretty optimistic. If I've learned anything over the past 10-15 years it's that there are a lot of stupid people voting against their interests in the US.
- skrause 11y agoYou can have mandatory paid leave without additional risks for the employers. In Germany for example the paid leave is partly paid for by the health insurance and partly by taxes. All the employer has to deal with is not to see the employee for a few months, but good management should have plans for that case anyway (e.g. dealing with sickess/accidents).
- cryoshon 11y agoThe German attitude to work is entirely different (better), though. I worked closely with a German boss for a few years, and the difference is ultra palpable. The entire way of working plans for sane hours (even when this is a struggle to make work), ample time to eat/rest while at work, plenty of vacation time (and no emails or bothering during that time or any time other than standard work hours where the employee is physically present at work), sick time, and time to get organized for projects. Meetings are viewed as last resorts because they're time/energy costly and typically low-productivity. Projects that don't fit that mold are put on hold until there's time for them. The American style is closer to "fuck you for thinking about slacking".
- mkaziz 11y agoMan, I gotta find me a German boss.
- theklub 11y agoJust depends where you work. I work 2-3 days a week and get paid for 5. This is in America. Hacker news is such an echo chamber for American hate.
- cryoshon 11y agoConversely, there are plenty of people who work for 7 days and get paid for 5. Anecdotes don't change the fact that labor protections are nonexistent and desperately needed in the US.
- theklub 11y agoNot arguing that but someone offer a German example so I'm offering an American one.
- jrwoodruff 11y agoObviously your situation is the exception, not the norm. I've worked a lot of jobs and met a lot of people, I can't name one person with such an arrangement. Even the self-employed folks that I know don't enjoy that amount of leisure time. You're very lucky. What line of work are you in?
- EliRivers 11y agoEconomy exists to serve the people, not the other way around. Making a "perfect" economy through the medium of miserable workers is failure.
- mc32 11y agoThey are not entities as such. If we granulated things such that everyone was self employed, some people would forgo self given benefits and some people would take all their self given benefits. Of course in this case people would be making that decision themselves, rather than a company.
- foldor 11y agoAm I the only one disgusted that women were only being given 10 weeks (Now reduced to 6, with 6 additional weeks for medical reasons) in the first place? This is one of the many workers rights areas that the US is far behind the rest of the modern world.
- jstx 11y agoClearly.
- kangman 11y agowhy does change always have to come with conflict on this side of the pond? It seems like the governments of EU members are more proactive then reactive when it comes to employee rights.
- Jtsummers 11y agoI think we read that line differently. My understanding was that biological mothers were given the standard 6 + an extra 6 + more if needed. They actually come out a bit ahead here, but it's still only 3 months. The company’s current policy — which went into effect this year — gives six weeks of paid caregiving leave to all new parents. Biological mothers receive another six weeks of leave, and more if they have additional medical needs. Quoted so people know what we're referring to. The sentence on biological mothers describes two things. The extra six weeks for being the biological mother, and additional time as needed (with some limits, but probably covered under insurance at this point) for medical conditions.
- marvin 11y agoFor comparison, Norwegian employees have the right to take in total (both parents combined) 49 weeks paid parental leave at 100% of their salary, or 59 weeks at 80% of their salary. For heterosexual couples, the father is required to take 10 weeks leave and the mother is required to take 9 weeks leave.
- 11y ago
- cryoshon 11y ago"In his complaint, Mr. Ayanna cited a “macho” culture that “encourages male associates and partners to fulfill the stereotypical male role of ceding family responsibilities to women.”" Ah yes, the good old macho culture that has been disfiguring men emotionally and physically for longer than I know. The macho culture is probably one reason why we don't live as long as women do, since we consider going to the doctor to be expressing weakness, which is verboten. Aside from that aspect of the issue, it's no secret that worker rights barely exist in the US, and a strong parental leave policy enshrined into law would massively help both men and women. Getting real worker rights in the US be like pulling teeth from a stone (sic), though. We don't even have sick days by law-- seems like those should come first. A quick list of things we direly need which we don't have: 1. Paid sick days 2. Paid vacation days 3. Hard limit of hours worked per week 4. Overtime pay for salaried employees 5. Paid parental leave 6. Control over scheduling of hours 7. A realistic minimum wage or some other way of guaranteeing survival of the poor 8. Paid childcare
- wang_li 11y agoI'm curious... when you travel do you pay extra for services you don't receive? For example, if you are going to stay in a hotel for five days, do you pay for seven?
- cryoshon 11y agoLabor isn't the same as other commodities, and shouldn't be treated in the same fashion. For instance, you don't go to the store, take a can of WD-40 home, use it, then go back to the store to pay for the can. Labor (unjustly, but not hugely so) is given to employers on credit from workers. You work a week (giving the commodity of labor away for free during that week because you have no choice in the matter) then get paid afterward. The point of this push for labor rights is that laborers aren't being fairly compensated in a variety of dimensions for the work they've done.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoYou said it! Contractors have it worse. You typically get paid net-60, you're actually working for a quarter for nothing and hoping the company is still solvent to pay you. E.g. start working Jan 1st; bill for the month on Jan 31st. Net-60 means getting paid for that April 1st. You work 90 days on hope.
- herge 11y agoQuebec has one of the best parental leave policies in North America, and it's all payed for by the government's unemployment payroll taxes, so there is little cost to companies (other than hiring a replacement). You basically get a full calendar year shared between the mother and the dad as you see fit at 70% of your salary. It has made having a child a lot easier, especially for young professionals.
- neap24 11y agoThat sounds wonderful...but does that mean if you have three children in a row you get three years off work and get paid for it? If so, that seems like it could be difficult for companies to work around.
- neap24 11y agoI was not thinking so much in terms of financial difficulty, but in terms of changing company culture. A lot can change at a company in three years. You may have to completely reorient the employee. Or...maybe since the employee has been absent for so long, their position is no longer valued/needed. The company shifts in a different direction without the employee there to shift with it. Can all jobs be easily replaced with a "temporary employee". If you have a lot of inside knowledge and training that allows you do perform well, it would take a lot of training to get a temp up to speed. Also, three children may be an "edge case", but two definitely is not and it seems like the same problems would apply.
- smartt 11y agoTrue, but this is an edge case that is unlikely given the toll that pregnancy takes on a woman's body and the challenges for the family. If you have kids, can you honestly say that you think this would be a good thing to try? Another issue is where the parental-leave financial support comes from. Should it be the company's responsibility, or is this a government initiative to invest in the health of its citizens? Would you support the idea if the company had zero financial responsibility for the paid-leave (and only had to bring the parents back on once leave is over?)
- herge 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]